Poll: New Mexico's Out of this World Ad Campaign

What do you think about New Mexico's 'the best place in the Universe' ad campaign? Great, terrible, genius? Since everyone seems to be talking about it, a quick, informal poll seemed in order:
Vote in the New Mexico Ad Campaign Poll
(Currently on the blog? Vote on the homepage. Votes are anonymous.)
Thoughts// In case you missed the story, New Mexico has launched a new ad campaign featuring aliens discussing a vacation to the state. However, according toan article released by the AP, some constituents in the land of enchantment are not so enchanted by the campaign, although it has won awards and praise from the advertising community.
While your opinion may differ on the execution of the creative, the PR value that the story has generated online cannot be overlooked.
Currently, Google Newscities 119 websites, newspapers and TV stations covering the story online. It was posted as one of the top 6 stories on the Yahoo! homepage yesterday afternoon, had 93 people recommend the story, 206 people email the story (the photo of the print ad alone has been emailed 149 times on Tuesday...as of 10:00am) and is the most popular story in the Yahoo! News Travel section.Several blogs have posted the storyand I am sure (if you are like me) someone emailed you the article yesterday. In my case, 7 times.
While most of this PR does (unfortunately) have a negative tone, it begs the question, is any PR good PR? When was the last time we saw a story about a state tourism campaign generate this much news?
And just as a side note, this froma USA Today readeron the campaign:
Would you rather have Arnold and Maria walking the beach telling you to come to "Cal E forni"
Good point.
More from the Travel 2.0 Blog
Featured Partner: GetSmartContent
With the launch of Travel 2.0 Consulting I have be...Travel Trends KLM on Twitter, Mobile Coupons, Ikea Heights
The latest travel trends from the Travel 2.0 blog.Case Study: Redesign With a Vengeance
Visit California is back with another site update....
blog comments powered by Disqus
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't these commercials come out months ago! Why the big push again?
The PR, good bad or indifferent, definitely makes people want to see the ad if they haven't already. The ads may not be very successful in terms of traditional advertising, but as a form of viral marketing they are genius.
Hi Molly,
Yes, as I recall these ads have been out for a while. I remember looking at them prior to ESTO in August.
However, the big push came from an AP article discussing the controversy the ads have caused within the state. Then, national media outlets, who are always looking for a story, picked it up.
All of which stemmed from, according to the AP story, a critical speech by Albuquerque CVB chief Dale Lockett in October.
So there you go, a brief history of the campaign.