Instant Case Study: Colorado.com, or 'Let's Talk Redesign!'
I love skinny dipping in random rivers...
Since it is a Friday, I figured a more lighthearted post was appropriate for this fine fall day. Not like a lot of our posts our that serious, I mean we have used William Shatner, the Blues Brothers and numerous other pop culture icons to keep the mood light. But, I digress.
Recently our friends and rivals to the north, Colorado, updated the overall look of their primary consumer site,Colorado.com. See below.
Similar toour post about the updated VisitCalifornia.com site, a quick review seemed in order.
Read the our thoughts and then let us know what you think. (Email or RSS readers, can't see the poll?Visit the Travel 2.0 blog to vote.)
Thoughts//This new site update actually highlights a conversation we have been discussing internally in terms of how visitors search and navigate through our sites. Depending on the visitor, are they more likely to search visually, use a search engine / box or use a more traditional text based navigation. The new Colorado.com site presents all 3, with an emphasis on the visual search.
Angry Travel Oregon note:Compare for yourself the new Colorado.com site vs.Oregon 365 sitein terms of visual search via images. Certainly some similarities there.
The new Colorado.com.
The first thing you notice about the new Colorado.com site is the very clean look of the homepage. Unlike the previous iteration, see below, the new site removes all of the irrelevant content and 'have to be on the homepage' fluff (yeah, sorry, it is marketing fluff) and focuses strongly on key areas.
Of course, looking at the old Colorado.com you can see that, like many CVB and DMO sites, the homepage was cluttered with a random sampling of content, text and images (sorry, the main image would not pull up for the screen shot) that one could safely assume would not apply to the majority of visitors.
The old Colorado.com
If I am going to Colorado for a vacation and interested in art museums, the lack of culture related content on the homepage is not helping my search.
Notice as well, the site now has a light and airy feel (primarily because of the reduction in content), the boxy design has been dramatically scaled back (thank you) and the search box has been moved the top of the page, rather than languishing in the gutter of the former site.
Overall, a great upgrade and one that was sorely needed. However, this new design is a big step away from the previous version and it will be interesting to see if the staff can resist the temptation and pressure to begin placing those 'have to be on the homepage' items back on the homepage.
From my experience, that is always the biggest challenge when designing a minimalistic homepage.
So, what do you think? Let's try out our new polling feature. The Colorado.com, love it or hate it? Vote and let us know what you think about the site byusing the comments section.
More from the Travel 2.0 Blog
14 Amazingly Real CVB / DMO Tweets
Well, it has come to this. Forget email or flyers...The State of Arizona
Travel is an experience that unites us. Pul...Case Study: Snowbird iPhone App
Today, let's take the conversation mob...
blog comments powered by Disqus
Review of Colorado.com Posted on October 17, 2008 by Keith The Travel 2.0 blog, run by a few CVB folks, did a review of Colorado.com's new design. Some good points. Check it out!
Nice Friday post Troy. Now..I wouldn't describe our reaction as "angry". Bemused and flattered might be more appropriate
In all seriousness, I do love the new "visual gateway to content approach"; very sophisticated way to tell people the CO story. I would like to however see that experience extended throughout the site. Once you pick an experience the site rather quickly becomes the ubiquitous "listings" driven site that we're all accustomed to.
Ha ha ha. Yes, the 'angry' line is a bit much, but controversy sells!
Completely agree on the content. The look of the new design is great, but as soon as you click on one of the images, it simply takes you to a listing of 'x.'
They are still missing the critical storytelling aspect of the site, that additional layer of content that truly sells the destination.
They are about 1/4 of the way there with this new look. Now, we need to see the actual story behind Colorado.
Right now, we aren't talking. We are just listening to you (Colorado) read a list.
Overall, I like the redesign. It does remind me a lot of Chicago's new site:http://www.choosechicago.com/Pages/default.aspx
It is a lot easier to keep the clean look when you can just focus on the leisure market. We in the CVB world have way more audiences to appease.
Great point Katie.
I think this segment of the travel industry, DMOs or CVBs, needs to realize that our websites are serving different purposes as well as consumers and should reflect that fact in the design.
In the case of Colorado, or any state, if the visitor is coming to the Colorado site there is clearly a much larger amount of information available than on a CVB site. Simply because of the difference in physical size.
The way you introduce that consumer to your information would be different on a state / region site vs. a CVB site.
If someone is visiting a DMO site they have either decided to visit a large part of the state, rather than a single location, or are trying to determine what single location to visit.
Once they get to the city site, I think we can safely assume that the visitor is either planning on visiting that specific city or trying to determine where in that city to visit. Which is an opportunity to present a much broader amount of info.
The difference is a 'just browsing' vs. a 'ready to buy' mind set.
Ah, more questions!
While it's definitely an improvement, and daring in its home page simplicity (speaking from the experience, it's no easy task), I'll echo the other comment about the disappointment that it turns back into a template listing in the internal pages. The incorporation of more images and even video within these pages would help to continue that aspirational feel of the home page, and ideally help excite 'browsers' into going the next step and plan a vacation. I'm not sure if that's more a symptom of the myColorado feature or not, but there's great opportunity beyond the home page.
While I like the cleaner design, the continually scrolling band of images that runs across the top of the inside pages is extremely annoying. It's difficult to read content when there's something moving in your peripheral vision. They need to add the ability for the user to stop/start this animation.
A few quick observations:
I am sure a large majority of users find the site via google and go to an interior page and never see the home page.
There is no easily visible navigation structure on the home page. For example, the "see, do, eat, stay, go" navigation links are treated visually exactly like the content header "Let's Talk Memories of a Lifetime," which isn't a link or clickable. This will be confusing to most users.
This continues throughout the site where you see headlines that are treated exactly like the navigation, but aren't clickable and then body text that is blue and not clickable, but is similar to the sub navigation.
the word "article" is a very non userfriendly term and is used throughout the site.
currently the site allows you to click on the breadcrumb of the page you are on, which just refreshes the page.
Hi Mike,
Thanks for the comments.
I completely agree, a majority of visitors certainly find the site via Google. And on the hierarchy of navigation or font treatments. Often overlooked.
like Colorado and the Oregon Coast, Wyoming uses photography as a navigational tool to tell the story of the
we love the visual selection option from a user perspective, we can't help but think we have seen this feature used somewhere else...now where was that. But, again, points for California, we like this execution