With all of the talk, hype and promotion of social channels by tourism destinations most still do not understand how to communicate instead of sell. New Mexico Tourism does not get it, does your destination?
Recently, I have been thinking about what the future of DMO, CVB and destination marketing looks like.
In a recent post (Your Tourism Destination Strategy is Wrong), we elaborated on a pillar of this new strategy, the need for speed. Simply put:Your new destination strategy is delivering valuable answers in less time than the other guy.
Unfortunately, far too many destinations do not understand this concept. Nor do they fully understand their place in social media. And frankly,few understand social media.
Case in point, theNew Mexico Tourism Department.
For a major state DMO that actively and prominently promotes their social channels, you would assume that a simple question would be an easy request.
Alas, our question fell upon deaf ears.
Although it was sent on a Friday, directly to the@nmtourismaccount and asked for specific help, we got nothing.
Nothing on Friday, nothing on Saturday, nor Sunday and not on Monday.
Ignored. Forgotten. And frankly, a little pissed.
Not because my question was not answered...I already knew where to eat, thebreakfast at Harry's Roadhouseis amazing...no, I am pissed because for all of the talk, hype and promotion of social channels, here is a destination that missed an perfect opportunity to:
- Establish itself as an expert.
- Promote a member or support a local business.
- Communicate and make a direct impact on tourism revenue in the state.
But the missed it. They failed.
A quick review of recent @nmtourism tweets highlights a clear misunderstanding of Twitter. No conversation, just tweet after tweet of promotion, specials and endless noise.
Let me make this as clear as possible,if you believe social media is a marketing tool you are wrong.
Social media is a communication opportunity.
An opportunity that can be rightfully rejected by the consumer for poor content, poor response or lack of speed.
You would never let a call to your call center go unanswered so why would you let a tweet drift into the internet ether?
Don't have the staff, resources or strategy? No problem, I have an answer.
Quit social media. Stop, cancel and delete your account until you are ready to commit.
Commit or quit.
New Mexico Tourism should quit.
What about your destination?
About The Author
Troy Thompson is a respected consultant, speaker and thought leader in the tourism industry. Principal and Senior Tourism Consultant at the
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group, Troy provides destinations, DMOs and CVBs with answers to difficult digital marketing questions.
Travel 2.0| Twitter| More articles from Troy Thompson
Great points Troy and some that have existed for far longer than social if you aren't going to be answering the call, don't have a call center but many organizations just see the shiny new toy aspect of social and jump in before they really understand the commitment(s) required. Some people "get it" inherently, and some just don't...it's both a challenge and an opportunity and one that you certainly need to be passionate about to succeed, therefore I love your post because it certainly conveys that passion well done!
Thanks @erichoffman:disqus , glad that came across as passion and not negative ranting. Overall, the social media opportunity for DMOs, CVBs and destinations is immense. Truly an opportunity to reclaim the mantle of the tourism expert.
But DMOs must recognize this opportunity and act upon it.
Not just register on a few social sites, post occasionally and count up followers.
That strategy is destine for failure.
I have said it for a long time, communication is key...and I still believe it.
Thanks for the comments.
Troy
You can now multiply this by a factor of a hundred to get a pretty accurate picture of DMO engagement with the social web on a global basis and how little understood this opportunity is by many. In the meantime, they are probably busy preparing RFPs to find a PR agency they think will help them to become social. Pitiful, really!
Short and sweet hits the nail on the head. My example I complained to Spyder about my ski coat falling apart heard nothing. Made me jealous of all the other Tweeters I see getting quick reactions and fixes to problems and made me hesitant to buy another Spyder coat. Why be in the mix on that site if you aren't paying attention?
Exactly, reply and talk to everyone, or no one.
Great comment.
Troy
Thank you Joe.
Folks, you don't need a PR agency to be social. You did need someone to help you with strategy, get you started, train your staff, etc., but to be social, no you don't *need* that.
Just start talking with other people.
Social problem solved.
Troy
Great post.. ballsy but I like it. Problem is this new world involves significant organisational change. Those DMOs who go first will learn and lead the industry. Might have to hire some people who like to tweet...
Great post.. ballsy but I like it. Problem is this new world involves significant organisational change. Those DMOs who go first will learn and lead the industry. Might have to hire some people who like to tweet...
Thanks @rodneypayne:disqus . Appreciate the ballsy kudos.
Agreed, this will involve change, and for that matter, pain. It will be painful for DMOs to accept, shift and embrace this model.
But you know what, I don't think Facebook, Twitter or communicating is going away.
There is a reason so many destinations don't think their social efforts are working, because they are just following, not leading.
Good stuff.
Troy
Almost as bad as those people who send tweets that are actually Facebook posts. Like the old adage, if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all; if you don't have 30 seconds to tweet, then don't tweet at all.
Brilliant...I am RTing that right now...and sending it to Facebook at the same time. ;)
Troy
Troy, I think this is a telltale symptom of DMOs/CVBs who farm out their social media to "experts" or get caught up in platforms that focus on operational efficiency rather than creating engagement through realtime conversation. I'm thinking of platforms that schedule out a month's worth of tweets, so someone who doesn't really care can check that off the punch list. We've probably all tried them, but in the end, there is no real value. Thanks a lot, robots!
@rodneypayne The organizational change starts with the corporate culture established at the top. From that follows the answer to the question of "WHY"? start at all. There are no short cuts and finding someone who can tweet is the last step, sort of like finding someone who can answer the phone well. Unfortunately too many start at that end. The result of that approach being what Troy reports here.
Indeed, there is a reason we did not call it 'robot media' and decide instead upon 'social media.'
Troy
Good post, Troy.
Great post Troy. As mentioned already, it's not helped by the structure of most DMOs. While some understand the need for it, there's a huge chasm between theory and practice, as evidenced by your post.
Over/under on the number of PR agencies 'specializing' in social media that are now forwarding the link to this post to the president of the NM Tourism along with a pitch...
Great post, with necessary bite. I work as a copywriter and content producer at a prominent DMO in Florida. Like many similar travel organizations, we initially struggled a bit with social media. We've thankfully moved past the "shiny object" phase, and now strategy and resources are appropriately aligned. But we're all still learning. Social media is still in its infancy as a communication medium, and no one is truly an expert (yet).
But taking shortcuts doesn't help , such as streaming your tweets on Facebook and LinkedIn in place of unique, native content. If you can't (or won't) take the time to develop your messaging for each social media platform, don't bother. Nothing comes across as lazy , or truly disingenuous , as the same 140 character message being embedded everywhere, regardless of each application's unique features. Talk about lost opportunities.
I already sent mine, but did not get a response. Ha!
Troy
So interesting that you post on this. I missed a tweet the other day. It didn't come through on my phone on a Friday night but showed up on my tweetdeck that next Monday. I replied to the guy said "hope you found a great place to dine and sorry I wasn't there for you" kind of message and all was ok. We bantered back and forth for a bit and it was positive about my destination. Would it have made you feel better if NM had acknowledged you? And do you expect to have instant access to that destination all the time? Interestingly enough, I was at a seminar that you taught and tweeted you a question on the way home and you never acknowledged my tweet. Should I have expected you to or should I have just written it off to the fact that you were traveling (which I did)? Or should I have written a blog blasting you as a social media expert for not monitoring and communicating with me? Thoughts?
Hi Stephanie, nice to hear from you and thanks for the comments.
Great points.
First, I was not hurt, personally, that New Mexico did not reply. Again, I already knew where I was going to eat, I simply wanted to see how New Mexico Tourism would respond. Do they actually reply to tweets, talk with consumers, etc.
Only after the tweet did I do a bit of digging and notice a lack of @ replies.
As for my lack of response to your tweet, I apologize. I can only assume the number of tweets from that speaking appearance caused that miss.
However, I think it is clear that I simply missed your tweet...considering my overall activity. In this case, New Mexico clearly does not reply to anyone, ever.
That is the difference, I could forgive and certainly would not have even started this article if it appeared to be a one time miss on a Friday. But when you fly the Twitter flag on your website, yes, I expect a response.
As for instant access, no, I don't expect it. And DMOs should not feel like they have to provide it. Post hours, update your bio, etc. But considering the elapsed time and they fact that @nmtourism:disqus has tweeted since, I felt that they either ignored my question or are simply not monitoring their feed.
Either way, it was a miss.
And let's be clear, New Mexico Tourism is just the example here, Santa Fe did not respond either and I would expect a majority of destinations would fail to respond as well.
That is the issue, not New Mexico Tourism, but an overall lack of strategy and understanding with social media.
Finally, I have never claimed to be a social media expert and will refuse any mention of the term.
So blast away, just don't call me an expert.
Troy
I think Motorad666 is onto part of the problem. Most DMOs have a traditional media Agency of Record. These agencies then pitch their "social media team" at the DMO, but because they're a trad agency with a traditoinal mindset, all they're doing is using social media as yet another broadcast channel.
Because most of the senior marketing folks at DMOs are not immersed in the new realities of social influence marketing, they respond positively to what sounds familiar (and therefore easier) to them.
Then the trad agencies shows them traditional success metrics of reach and frequency (which are very cheap to accomplish with social ) and the agency looks good and the execs are happy. I've actually seen "impressions" on Twitter presented as a KPI.
Except the potential visitors are clicking unlike, unfriend, unfollow in droves.
So it's not that outsourcing to "experts" is bad outsourcing to bad experts is bad. I don't think this situation will change until more "native" soc med agencies get their feet in the DMO door, and the senior DMO execs get their heads around the seismic shift that has happened in their industry. Just because it's hard, doesn't mean you don't have to do it.
Great thoughts Paul, thank you for sharing.
Troy
I find it hard to believe there are many agencies out there being this short sighted. Is the focus on broadcast messaging and easy to grasp traditional metrics there because that is what agencies are pitching, or because that is what DMO leadership is asking for? It seems likely to me that most agencies have at least a couple of folks on board that truly understand the new reality, but convincing a client that doesn't yet is far from easy, whether you're a new school SM agency trying to win new business or an old school soup to nuts agency pitching an existing client on trying something new.
If you're the agency of record for a DMO and they're asking questions about social media, you're going to pitch them on it. Most likely that pitch is going to involve exactly what they should be doing. But if they don't bite because they're not ready to take the blue pill yet, well then you're going to back off and do SM exactly like they want you to, hoping that with your foot in the door you'll be able to slowly move them from their incomplete understanding to a complete and progressive one.
Probably. It would take a very principled agency to decline SM business just because an existing client wasn't ready to do it 100% right yet.
I have no doubt you're right that in at least some cases, it's the DMOs driving the (ineffective) approach, Donnie, but I've had first hand experience of the reverse on multiple occasions. It does happen, and maybe more than we realize
I have seen the hours of operation bio a couple of times. For destinations where a visitor center employee or just a 9 5 FTE is managing the account, it is a great idea.
Or, list the phone number or, better yet, have your URL link go to a contact page for the CVB. For Tupelo, I would send them to http://www.tupelo.net/contact/.
But include your phone number, VIC address (w/ Google Map), email, Twitter, Facebook on that contact page. Give the consumer options to reach you.
The other tactic I love is partnering with a local hotel. Since the hotel is staffed 24/7, see if you can work a partnership where the CVB and hotel share tweeting responsibilities. That way, the hotel can post / respond on the weekends.
Overall, don't feel pressure to be on 24/7. Be open and honest when you are available, people will respect that.
As for your tweeting skills, they look good. Just be yourself and be helpful...which is clear from your bio!
Troy
Well that is just a shame. Those agencies are going to need to do some serious soul searching if they're to survive the next decade.
Troy, I like your points. I am a local hotel and our DMO doesn't tweet. I try to stay on the lookout for our destination but miss occasionally. Luckily, I am in a small area with a unique name : )
I will definitely post more info out there about tweeting hours and coverage and phone number.
I am wondering how you feel about a hotel tweeting back to tweets about an area, trying to answer questions, etc. Does it intimidate the person who tweeted who didn't stay at our hotel but visited our town? or should I just engage as I would if I were the DMO, asking about visit, answering questions, retweeting their positive comments, etc?
I go back and forth, sometimes I use my hotel handle, sometimes I use my more generic handle. In this case, I created another twitter handle @VisitOurayCO and try to use that so as not to get "in your face" but provide the info but managing two accounts is kinda tricky.
I just found your blog recently but it really is informative. I thank you!
Great Post Troy! I am currently in the early stages of consulting with a client that is eager to use SM as a marketing and sales channel. I keep insisting that the client needs to establish itself as an expert and respond to any tweets (direct or indirect) with a timely and appropriate response. This means not simply directing them back to view their online portal, as they have been doing in the past (whether their sites answers the question/problem or not).
Something that needs to be addressed for anyone seeking to participate in social media.
Before I came on board I gave them the same ultimatum Either your commit or I'm not coming on board. It was refreshing to say the least!
Thanks again for the great post!
Michael
The smartest thing that New Mexico and Santa Fe could do right now is come respond to this post.
Placing bets right now as to whether they ever do, because....
1) They have no idea that this conversation is going on because they don't know "how to listen" online, and
2) If they do know about it, they don't realize that a response is not only desired, but required, by the mores and culture of this space.
Keep pounding, Troy. You're right and they are not.
Great thoughts Sheila.
I should say, I did direct a tweet to them earlier today, offering an opportunity to respond.
However, while the post uses the New Mexico story as an example, this is truly a call to all DMOs to understand the opportunity that social media presents their destination.
Thanks for the comment.
Troy
Brilliant stuff, love that story.
Troy
Thanks for the comments, glad you found us.
I always advocate for transparency. Tell them you are a hotel when you are tweeting. That said, there is no reason why, as a local hotel, you cannot claim the role of the tourism expert in town.
I had a previous lodge client ask about social media topics...they had been tweeting and posting just about deals, events, etc...without much success.
In building their strategy, we discovered that they were a major draw for fishermen and hunters. So, we positioned their social media presence as the local expert for fishing and hunting.
They began providing updates on lake levels, fishing spots, hunting permits, etc. That tactic, in conjunction with a focus on communication began to expand their social presence as well as their profile as an expert and a lodge.
I would recommend just holding the CVB Twitter handle until the CVB is ready to engage. Until then, direct followers to your hotel profile and tell them you tweet about the hotel, local attractions, what to do, etc.
Great comments and questions, thank you.
Troy
Question: did you scan their feeds to see if they are missing "all" of these types of "need rec'ds tweets"? Could it be they just missed yours and by the time they were on TweetDeck or whatever they use, it was far down the stream and it just got missed?
Or, as you suggest, is this just one example of a trend that would indicate a clear lack of knowledge on the part of the DMO.
Hey Tom, good question.
I did a quick scan of their tweet patterns and it appeared that they did not have a lot of replies or direct questions sent to them. So, I assume that mine was still near the top of the stream.
For me, it illustrates the challenges and opportunities DMOs still have with social. It is not enough to post the Twitter logo on your website and occasionally tweet about an event.
It is a social contract between the destination and the visitor. If the DMO is not going to fulfill that contract, don't be surprised when Twitter does not provide ROI.
Good thoughts, thanks.
Troy
Thanks Troy, I appreciate your feedback!
Thanks John.
I agree Twitter may not be for everyone, but for most destinations I would not write off the social site simply due to personal preference.
Troy