Skip to content
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Strategy for tourism destinations

Feature

Death, Taxes and DMOs

No destination will market itself. It takes people to articulate the beauty, wonder and feeling of a place. People with pride, passion and a belief in tourism. Are you that person?

No destination will market itself. It takes people to articulate the beauty, wonder and feeling of a place. People with pride, passion and a belief in tourism. Are you that person?

Tourism is a gift that can be removed as swiftly as it appeared.

Last week, our friends in Washington had their Office of Tourism shuttered in an effort to save a meager $2 million dollars and close a $5.2 billion (B!) dollar budget gap.

The 'savings' amounts to animpact of 0.0003% to the overall shortfallin the Evergreen State.

And yet reasonable people, like you or I, thought this was a good idea.

Why?

How could this happen?

Because CVBs, DMOs and the entire tourism industry is viewed as a luxury, not a necessity to cities, states and regions.

It is the reason whyWashington State Tourism was eliminatedwith little fanfare (Bill GeistandReyn Bowmannotwithstanding) and the explanation for ourlong overdue addition of a national DMO.

Simply put, lawmakers and Joe Public view the tourism industry with a very basic perspective:

Tourism = Vacation. Vacation = Fun. Fun Necessity.

Police officers = Necessity.

Firemen = Necessity.

Education = Necessity.

Tourism funding should not be viewed as an expendable luxury, but rather as an economic foundation of great cities.

Even with a world class destination, tourism promotion is required.

Cities will not promote themselves. Natural wonders do not tweet their merits. Culture cannot tell stories.

Passionate people bring visitors to a destination.

And passionate people must stand up for a destination. Educate the public. Build trust. Create a community where the loss of tourism is seen as a loss of a critical public service.

Where the loss of tourism is lamented alongside the loss of public parks, schools and jobs.

No doubt there are passionate tourism advocates in Washington, unfortunately their passion was not seen as critical to the state budget.

Tourism is a critical service.

Even in Washington.

About The Author

Troy Thompson is a respected consultant, speaker and thought leader in the tourism industry. Principal and Senior Tourism Consultant at the
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group, Troy provides destinations, DMOs and CVBs with answers to difficult digital marketing questions.

Twitter| Google+| More articles from Troy Thompson

  • http://donnieclapp.com Donnie Clapp

    Natural wonders do not tweet *their* merits ; ). Good post. How do you think we make this happen?

  • / Troy Thompson

    Got it, thank you for proofing.

    As for making it happen...it is a constant push to change the perception of those outside the travel industry to recognize the important and necessity of tourism.

    Personally, I see DMOs pushing and pulling back on the amount of industry relations depending on the letter next to the governor's name (R or D), when what is required is a consistent message of tourism.

    Making it happen is going to require more effort than just one post...perhaps a follow up is in order.

    Troy

  • http://twitter.com/lindsontheroad Lindsay Young

    I feel like the perception of tourism as unnecessary in America is linked to the fact that most organisation in the States offer only 2 weeks vacation each year...and aren't too pleased when people actually take it.

    Compare this with Europe or Australia/New Zealand, where many countries (I'm specifically thinking the UK, Germany, Australia, and NZ) get 4 6 weeks vacation and have DMOs that are well funded and viewed as integral services. NZ is consistently considered one of the best DMOs in the world.

    Here in Canada, however, our DMO is strong, well funded, and since it finally raised us to #1 country brand in the world last year (FutureBrand Index), it's considered pretty integral. Contrary to my theory, though, we only get 2 or 3 weeks vacation (generally speaking).

    Anyway, I think it's an interesting situation in the States, and the fact that there's no national DMO speaks to something. It appears as though (not to be rude), there's a feeling that America is so great that it WILL promote itself. I mean, it's the 3rd most (?) visited country in the world. Also, most Americans are domestic travellers, so I bet that's why there's more focus on state DMOs rather than a national DMO (which would be designed to promote externally for international inbound).

    This is a bit long, but essentially, I'm saying that the perspective in the States seems to be unique. Most other nations recognise the importance of tourism, and wouldn't be facing problems like this.

    I'd be interested to hear what you have to say in a follow up post :)

  • / Troy Thompson

    Great comment Lindsay, thank you.

    I think you are spot on. We have a completely different view of travel in the US. From vacation length to promotion, we see tourism as a luxury, not an integral part of the economy.

    Our American pride is one of our greatest strengths, and sometimes a great weakness.

    Good stuff.

    And yes, it feels like a follow up post is coming. ;)

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Great comment Lindsay, thank you.

    I think you are spot on. We have a completely different view of travel in the US. From vacation length to promotion, we see tourism as a luxury, not an integral part of the economy.

    Our American pride is one of our greatest strengths, and sometimes a great weakness.

    Good stuff.

    And yes, it feels like a follow up post is coming. ;)

    Troy

  • http://donnieclapp.com Donnie Clapp

    Basically, the US is the only developed country whose people dont't view recreation/leisure/vacation as a necessary part of a good/happy/worthwhile life. All the other errors in how we view it, such as in regards to how integral it is to the economy, follow from that.

  • http://buhlerworks.com/wordpress JEBworks

    This problem is as old as tourism itself and will likely remain one, for the many reasons and false beliefs you list in your post.

    It starts with the mistaken idea that government "subsidizes" tourism and that this is a "luxury" when budgets are squeezed, and when are they not! The free market supporters would argue against public funding along these well known lines that tourism
    marketing should be left entirely to the private travel & tourism
    sector which benefits most directly from it.

    What these politicians don't realize and maybe, just maybe, it's at least partly because the tourism industry doesn't make a consistent, compelling argument, supported by a strong lobby is that paying for tourism marketing is an "investment" like any economic other with actually a wider circle of beneficiaries than is commonly believed. The butcher, the baker and the proverbial candlestick maker all would be worse off without visitors.

    In practice and it's been proven by many destinations around the globe the ideal funding formula is a combination of private and public sector contributions. The mix can be different based on each situation. Many studies have shown that for each unit of public investment a large multiple of private money follows. An additional benefit of mixed funding, is usually less focus on bureaucracy and more on accountability as to how these funds are spent most effectively with the highest ROI.

    There is nothing wrong with a strong breeze of private sector initiative, transparency and efficiency when it comes to destination marketing.

  • Anonymous

    I guess people in general feel that the private sector (hotels, attractions, restaurants, cultural heritage sites for example) are responsible for their own marketing and need to "foot the bill" themselves. The problem there is that to build that compelling story for a destination requires all kinds of infrastructure, attractions, accommodations and the like to assist the traveler and those are not direct marketing expenses to the private sector business.

    The state budget funds creating the exchange (the place where people who dream of a Colorado vacation can go to see the various offerings). States that are huge like Colorado or Washington are so vast that the collection of things to do makes a big dent in the minds of a traveler. It is hard to string attractions and events and accommodations together in a meaningful itinerary without assistance. If you are a world renowned destination like Vail then maybe state funding isn't required. However, if you are a quaint mountain town (like my town of Ouray Colorado) the state funding is essential as it helps bring people to the area. It isn't the states responsibility to get folks into my business. I own that angle! But, to get people to Colorado just helps keep money in motion and fuels jobs and spending...

    And, let us also not forget that many people want to be spoon fed... they want a prebuilt itinerary that tells you what to do on each day so that they maximize their fun with minimal work on their end. I wonder if the state will have a different feeling when the overall sales tax collections fall short because people chose to go to Oregon rather than Washington... cuz Oregon sent the marketing messages that said, come see us, here is our story!

  • / Troy Thompson

    Could not agree more. Everyone has a role in the tourism ecosystem...and when one part disappears, the rest of the system suffers.

    Maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow, but the effect of this loss will be felt by our tourism friends in Washington.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks Joe, always appreciate your seasoned perspective.

    Love the idea of 'investment.' Everyone should really use that word much more often.

    Troy

About the author

> Tweet No destination will market itself. It takes people to articulate the beauty, wonder and feeling of a place. People with pride, passion and a belief in tourism. Are you that person? is a contributor to the Travel 2.0 journal.