Skip to content
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Strategy for tourism destinations

Marketing

Suffocating Your Social Strategy

For many DMOs and CVBs, a social media agency is a needed resource for strategic advice and experienced execution.

For many DMOs and CVBs, a social media agency is a needed resource for strategic advice and experienced execution. But even when hiring an expert, our own restrictions on the campaign can erode the success before the first retweet.

Ah social. Has anything inspired and confused more tourism marketers over the last 5 years?

From a strategy perspective, I think our opinions on the subject are pretty clear (you can catch up with a quick glance through our archives) and yet on a regular basis we continue to see DMOs and CVBs making common mistakes.

Recently, I reviewed a RFP for a social media marketing firm. The goal was for the firm to handle the strategy and execution of the social efforts on behalf of the CVB.

Nothing wrong with that per se. Personally, I believe in the in house approach first, but there are situations that call for an external firm.

No, the issue was the suffocating nature of the RFP which not only stipulated exactly what to talk about, but on what networks and how often.

A minimum of twenty (20) posts per week is required.

Yeah, that line is directly from the document.

I get it, traditional marketers are use to providing exact specifics when they start a campaign. Length of the TV ad, size of the print ad or frequency of the PPC keyword.

We have been trained to run our marketing programs with precision.

No one would ever sayoh, just run that TV ad when it feels right.

Which is why DMOs and CVBs, like the one in our example, attempt to place their social efforts in the same, restrictive box as the rest of the advertising campaign.

Yet we all know that social cannot be bound by traditional restrictions. Social is, well, social. The conversation is dictated by two groups, the marketer and the consumer, and therefore, does not respond to traditional specs and directions.

Unfortunately this CVB will learn that lesson the hard way.

And when they ask themselves why the selected social agency was not a good fit, it will not be because of the agency's expertise.

No, it will be because of the suffocating specifications on this social strategy.

Troy Thompson

Troy Thompson is a respected consultant, speaker and thought leader in the tourism industry. Principal at theTravel 2.0 Consulting Groupand Founder ofmark, Troy provides destinations, DMOs and CVBs with answers to difficult digital marketing questions.

Twitter| Google+| More Articles

  • http://buhlerworks.com/wordpress JEBworks

    Another great example of ass backwards, pardon my French! Focus on the tactical tools at the expense of a solid strategy based on overall, clear marketing objectives. When it all fails blame the consultant or agency. Rinse and repeat..... Pitiful, really.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Exactly Joe, exactly.

    No worries on the French, we are trying to be more international.

    It is just tough to see a smart destination, sending out a RFP, with this type of language in it. I get the need to provide some direction, but to handcuff the agency with posting rules and requirements before the first face to face meeting just does not make sense.

    Frankly, I would not be surprised if most of the 'good' agencies simply passed on this RFP due to the obvious lack of understanding around social.

    Troy

  • http://buhlerworks.com/wordpress JEBworks

    No wonder those who use this process end up with mediocre agencies. Many of the top ones don't bother with participating in the silly game.

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    Bang on the money, as usual, Troy (and something that, as you know, I'm dealing with myself, unfortunately).

    I get *why* DMOs are still in this mindset. I really and truly do. We're still in the very nascent, incipient stages of social media as a marketing platform (ESPECIALLY for destinations), and traditionally DMOs are staffed by people with experience in the traditional channels sales, print / CPG marketing, etc. We haven't hit the point yet where senior staffers have been working in the digital realm for the bulk of their careers, and as a result, the inclination is to force traditional marketing practices upon social media campaigns even though to do so is roughly akin to trying to fix your leaky kitchen faucet with a bazooka.

    In the era of Google, TripAdvisor, Yelp and so on, especially with Google now taking direct aim at the hotel and flight booking markets, social and email are the last two lines of defense a DMO has to remain relevant, valuable and authentic authenticity particularly coming from social. Ultimately, you can't FORCE a conversation to happen. Life doesn't work that way.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Good stuff Tim, thanks.

    I think you are spot on with the idea that the senior teams within DMOs are missing that direct digital experience. Or at least, deep roots in digital.

    And the line about social and email being the last lines of defense is telling, true and sobering.

    Troy

  • patrickdh

    "The conversation is dictated by two groups, the marketer and the
    consumer"; maybe starting to see it as conversations dictated between the consumer and the consumer would help to rethink the marketer's place before the RFP goes out.

About the author

> > Tweet Buffer 6 Comments > For many DMOs and CVBs, a social media agency is a needed resource for strategic advice and experienced execution. But even when hiring an expert, our own restrictions on the campaign can erode the success before the first retweet. is a contributor to the Travel 2.0 journal.