Skip to content
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Strategy for tourism destinations

Feature

Forecast 2012: The Micro Agency

Small is the new big. And for ad agencies, ideas, not content, is king. Call it a gut feeling, but in 2012, the unique ideas in destination marketing are coming from smaller shops and.

Small is the new big. And for ad agencies, ideas, not content, is king. Call it a gut feeling, but in 2012, the unique ideas in destination marketing are coming from smaller shops and freelance talent.

The meeting room was covered in that odd, fake redwood that seems to be native to only boardrooms and lecture halls. Around a large, ominous table floated two dozen black, leather chairs, the kind that become increasingly uncomfortable with each passing PowerPoint slide.

As I watched thesales specialistacross from me, I wondered if sport coats and t shirts looked good on anyone.

Then, he said it.

And we are more than capable of helping with your traditional advertising, brand work or even SEO/SEM.

The line had been crossed.

Pitch over.

Now, if that work of literary prose did not paint an accurate picture, let me summarize. Each year, I sit in my fair share of agency pitch meetings while helping my clients decipher and decode ad agency speak into standard English.

And, without fail, the agency rep on the other side of the table cannot help himself, touting the never ending capabilities of their organization.

In the illustration above, my client was looking for an email marketing partner.

Nothing more.

Which brings us to a developing trend within destination marketing organizations...and their advertising agencies.

More and more, organizations are looking for a combination of three factors:

  1. The best idea.
  2. The best fit.
  3. The best price.

And more often that not, a combination of smaller agencies is filling the role of the large, incumbent agency.

Perhaps there is more talent within smaller shops and the freelance community.

Perhaps the traditional ad agencies, and yes, even the new digital shops, have simply stretched themselves too far and too thin in the hopes of capturing a bigger piece of the budget.

Or perhaps our DMO peers are in need of a new perspective.

On second thought, it might be the traditional ad agency that needs the new perspective.

Troy Thompson

Troy Thompson is a respected consultant, speaker and thought leader in the tourism industry. Principal at theTravel 2.0 Consulting Groupand Founder ofmark, Troy provides destinations, DMOs and CVBs with answers to difficult digital marketing questions.

Twitter| Google+| More Articles

  • http://twitter.com/jebbanner Jeb Banner

    I have to wonder whether this is really the future micro agencies. I think we are moving more towards ecosystems and away from specializations. SEO is PR is content is usability, etc. To some degree I think we need agencies that are integrated. You can't just focus on one piece anymore, it doesn't work. All pieces must be working together which, I believe, means we will see a push back towards web generalists who can speak the language of the web even if they aren't proficient in a specific dialect (ie Twitter).

  • http://twitter.com/mosherifdeen mosherifdeen

    Totally agree. I've always been about hiring small, nimble, specialists on rafts vs a giant carrier fleet.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks Mo.

    I like that...the giant carrier fleet. Nice.

    And goodness knows I am not paying for 'Beer Friday' for the whole fleet.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Hey Jeb, first thanks for the comment. Always appreciated.

    An interesting take, and frankly, I like the ecosystem idea. While I am speaking from a tourism perspective, I still don't see that ecosystem in many of the larger agencies.

    Perhaps the answer is a collaboration between smaller shops and independents that represent the best of breed for the client.

    I have rarely found an agency that was best of breed for everything I, or my client, required.

    I had to piece the agency together, and in 2012, that process is getting easier.

    Troy

  • http://twitter.com/jebbanner Jeb Banner

    Thanks Troy, I appreciate the thoughtful post and response! I think that an integrated web agency (like mine SmallBox) has to have expertise across a number of key areas design/UX, development, SEO, email and Social but also have good partner relationships (like we do with Slingshot SEO and others) in order to go deeper in one area when needed. Still, that holistic, integrated approach is key to navigating the web c.2012 and in the years to come. I think specialty shops may find themselves forced to expand their services to accommodate the realities of effective marketing (ie communicating) within an ecosystem.

    Also, I know from many experiences that having a number of small agencies working together, even with one main agency as the lead, can get messy and expensive very quickly. This leads to redundancy and inconsistency which degrades the impact of the work as a whole. It can be done but it is a little like herding cats.

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    Brilliant post, as always, Troy.

    I used to work with a guy who liked to say that his firm did "website development, brand development, graphic design, photo and video, branding, publishing and applied social media." What in the WORLD?

    The fact of the matter is that it is impossible, utterly impossible, for one company to be a one stop shop for everything. To be great at social media requires a very specific organizational philosophy, just as to be great at service requires a very specific organizational philosophy, just as to be great at Web development requires a very specific organizational philosophy repeat ad nauseam for essentially every single specialty in digital marketing.

    Look at Google for as great as that company is at so many things, be it search, email, analytics, so on and so forth, they STILL don't get social, and they're only starting to figure bits and pieces out after throwing hundreds of millions of dollars at it and poaching staff from other firms. And that's because Google isn't a social organization it's a very tightly controlled, structured company and doesn't have the nimble, fluid philosophy to truly succeed in social. For all its bonuses, Google+ is still a social network built for power users, not the dude playing on his laptop while the football game is on in the background.

    I would never put all my eggs in one basket with an agency, and I wouldn't trust an agency that tried to position itself as one which could fulfill that role. Find what you're good at, and be awesome at it, and learn new skill sets as they arise. But it's the same in this field as it is everywhere else in life: It's fine and dandy to be a jack of all trades, but when you're a master of none, you're going to be lost in the shuffle instead of being the purple elephant that everyone notices.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Anytime, nice to make the connection.

    I agree with the idea of the holistic approach, but don't often see it completed properly. Most of the time, it feels like a hasty add on to simply capture more business.

    If you (the agency) have built and promoted your expertise in, say, digital development and then during the pitch process you say 'oh, we do branding work too' that is a red flag.

    And I have seen that scenario occur numerous times.

    Not to say it can't be done, but from a client perspective, the DMOs, CVBs and tourism organizations I work with...they are getting tired of it. And actively looking for greater specialization, rather than 'we do everything.'

    Finally, completely agree about the multiple agency model. It can, and often does get messy, quickly. However it can be done, if you have the right lasso.

    Love the conversation on this topic, thanks again.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks Tim.

    I think there are a few agencies that are truly great at everything related to marketing. But those firms are so large, they are simply out of scope for 99% of DMOs and CVBs.

    And, FYI, those firms are great at everything because they purchase smaller, specialized firms who made a name being great at one thing.

    Anyway, for Madison, Baltimore, Salt Lake City, even Los Angeles, I would be concerned if a single agency told me they could do everything, exceptionally well, within my budget.

    I must say, this post, out of the entire Forecast series, was the toughest to write. Because it is truly built around a gut feeling and supported by anecdotal evidence from my clients and peers.

    But when I ask DMO peers why the left agency X or digital shop Y, the answer is more often than not, because they lost focus.

    And I am not seeing any slow down in that trend.

    Troy

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    Loss of focus is a problem popping up more and more, not just on the agency side but on the DMO side, as well. Just as there are some agencies that got too hungry and expanded too quickly without having the infrastructure in place to handle the sudden influx of new clients, there are DMOs that still have no idea of what their messaging is, who the target audience is, and what they want that audience to do in response, and instead march forward, inexorably, like lemmings off a cliff.

    For any marketer agency or DMO to have that kind of false pride, to insist that, "No, WE ARE a special, delicate flower, and the problems which befall others aren't our problem," is nothing short of signing your own death warrant.

  • http://twitter.com/DeepDishCreates Lara Dickson

    Creating the illusion of being a full service agency is par for the course. An agency producing great work might have a total of 3 partners, employees, and janitors, but they can tout their full serviceness because they farm most of the grunt work out to freelancers and contractors like myself. Like someone mentioned earlier in the comments, its the small, nimble specialists on rafts tethered together that create the illusion of the giant carrier they are selling you on.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks Lara, you certainly know how this game is played.

    I guess that is my real issue. Why don't (most) agencies realize it is okay to *not* be great at everything? I would rather you tell me, than try to fake it.

    Troy

About the author

> > Tweet Buffer 11 Comments > Small is the new big. And for ad agencies, ideas, not content, is king. Call it a gut feeling, but in 2012, the unique ideas in destination marketing are coming from smaller shops and freelance talent. is a contributor to the Travel 2.0 journal.