Facebook and Twitter dominate our social lives, both personally and professionally. But as we move into 2012 an odd pattern is developing. More and more destinations are experimenting with other social sites to deliver a more relevant message.
It all sounds so simple.
Create a Facebook profile, send a couple of tweets and check, social media marketing strategy complete. At least, that is what the playbook looks like for most destination and tourism marketers.
But on our way to total and complete marketing reliance via the big two, a funny thing happened. More and more, our DMO / CVB peers...especially those on the bleeding edge...are drawing away from the saturated landscape of wall posts and RTs to instead place strategic focus on a handful of other social sites.
Namely,Pinterest,Foursquare,FoodspottingandInstagram.
That's right, new social networks.
But these other social sites might just be more relevant for your destination than Facebook or Twitter.
Pinterestis, at it's core, a bookmarking tool.
But instead of text links, the social / mobile service places a singular focus on images. In fact, everything added to Pinterest must have an image associated with it.
While the site launched with a distinct flavor of DIY, it has since matured to include anything and everything people want to accomplish...be it food, craft or travel. And that is where it gets interesting for destinations.
One of the first and mostactive DMOs on Pinterest, Experience Columbus, is experiencing growth with leisure travelers and event planners utilizing the service.
As Joe Vargo from Experience Columbus explains, Pinterest is not just a pretty memory keeper.
Pinterest isn't really about crafts , it's about aspirations. It is a reflection of what they want their lives to be like, and for those interested in travel, we are giving them reasons to come now, rather than later.
I love that idea. Aspirations. Is there a better word to describe the philosophy of a DMO?
Pinterest is a window into the inspiration phase of travel planning.That mysterious, often unreachable bucket list of locations, excursions and destinations that most of us have, but rarely share with others (at least, share effectively).
Pinterest is not just a bookmarking site, it is an opportunity to engage with potential visitors at the very top of the travel planning funnel. And that is interesting.
Foursquare
Old news, right?
But before you write off the check in crazy mobile game, take a look at what Foursquare has been doing with all of the information you left behind.
Namely, buildingFoursquare Explore.
Launched initially as a mobile extension of the already popular app, Foursquare Explore is now available as web version. Essentially a search engine. A search engine that knows exactly where, when and what your friends like to do (assuming they use Foursquare). According to Foursquare, the Explore product representspersonalized search for the real world.
For brands already using and creating content within Foursquare,such as Travel Channel, Explore means their content is now the Google equivalent of organic search results.
And considering the 1,500,000,000 (yeah, 1.5 billion, with a 'B') check ins that Foursquare has received, tracked and analyzed, there is a whole lot of content to plan your next trip around.
Foodspotting
Food is a companion to travel.
It is a reason to go and a reason to return. It is as unique to a destination as the geography, culture or people. And more accurately, a reflection of those influences. For some, food is more than basic necessity, it is a passion. And no social site presents that passion more effectively thanFoodspotting.
While we havepreviously wrote about the unique opportunities via Foodspotting, it is worth repeating due to the strong connection between food and tourism destinations.
Simply put, if your destination has been built upon the strength of your regional fare, then you need to be active within the Foodspotting community.
Or at least finding a good, local spot for lunch.
Anyone can take a great photo.
At least through the lens ofInstagram.
The iPhone app has struck a photo sharing vein of popularity in the last 6 months with more than 15 million users...and counting. Unlike other photo / effect apps, Instagram takes your photo further through a simple sharing mechanism. Like Twitter, you have your own stream of photos and can follow the photo streams of friends, family and strangers.
If Flickr felt a bit too professional for Joe Shutterbug, Instagram has stripped away the veneer of required skill (for better or worse), allowing anyone and everyone to share photos of their vacation to Maui.
Photos that, ironically, look professional.
Instagram is mobile, instant and enables someone of any skill level to snap a photo... It is also becoming a vital part of how people share in real time.Amy Brock, Visit Savannah
For destinations, Instagram is quickly becoming the default service for taking and sharing photos. Being able to tap into this community, via promotions such asLA INC.'s Photo Walk LA, is a massive opportunity to promote your region via the power of the photo.
Troy Thompson
Troy Thompson is a respected consultant, speaker and thought leader in the tourism industry. Principal at theTravel 2.0 Consulting Groupand Founder ofmark, Troy provides destinations, DMOs and CVBs with answers to difficult digital marketing questions.
Twitter| Google+| More Articles
While I'm adamant, fiercely so, that social is one of the few remaining avenues for a DMO to stay relevant and authentic in the days, weeks and months to come, I've never been convinced that Facebook is the ultimate social tool (for a destination) that everyone likes to pretend it is. There are applications for it (beyond a widget on your website, Facebook is probably the best way to get opt ins for your mailing list), but even with all the functionality of Pages, at its core, Facebook is still a person to person social network. And, at the end of the day, anything you do on Facebook or Twitter is simply attempting to convince someone to click a link.
I'm impressed with the already existing applications, and potential for new ideas, of Instagram and Pinterest for destinations. I'm not surprised that the (awesome) folks at Columbus are doing great things with Pinterest; when it comes to DMOs who "get" social and interactive marketing, they're among the very best.
Still not sold on FourSquare as a tool for DMOs proper, though, since everything is done at the venue level. About the only really legitimate use I can think of (for now, anyway) is if the DMO has a kickin' awesome visitors center and there's a benefit (coupon to a partner restaurant or something) to a check in there.
Troy, this is strong example of the thought provoking, against the grain, post that you are known for. But, I can't really understand how DMO's interactive marketers, already overwhelmed with work, will find the time to manage these peripheral opportunities. The justification for FB presence is as much for organic search as it is for fan engagement.
Thanks Tim.
Perhaps Foursquare is less of an opportunity and more of a threat. Hmm.
I do see Foursquare as an opportunity to enrich content, like the Brooklyn Museum ( http://ow.ly/8yauR ). Either way, it is a social network that DMOs should explore and understand.
Troy
Thanks Jake.
Certainly our DMO peers do already have enough work on their plates. But, as I have said consistently, not all of these social networks...including Facebook and Twitter...are right for each destination.
A DMO certainly does not have to be present on all of the examples above. But, if there is a good fit, they should explore it.
And like I said the other day... Forecast 2012: The New Facebook ( http://ow.ly/8yaQy )...perhaps Facebook is the social network that should be dropped.
Thought provoking, yes?
Troy
No, Troy, I don't see Foursquare as a threat, but at the same time, I don't see it as a great opportunity (for the DMO). It's not like Facebook, Twitter, or even Pinterest / Instagram, where the user is directly interacting with the DMO. It's all at a location based level. It's incumbent upon the specific location / venue to properly use Foursquare.
I'm not saying that's a bad thing at the end of the day, our job is to promote the businesses, organizations and attractions which make our destination a wonderful place to visit. If they do well and attract tourists (and locals), we're doing our job. But the opportunity for a DMO to do direct promotion through Foursquare is effectively nil (same with Yelp and TripAdvisor what the hell is a DMO going to do on those websites? Spam them with fake reviews? I should certainly hope not).
A case can be made for the idea that the DMO can do its part to encourage those businesses, organizations and attractions to participate in Foursquare and to show them the benefit, but the actual ROI on that is pretty much nonexistent, especially since there's probably a "Social Media (Destination)" type organization already in the area, dedicated to helping businesses better grasp and understand how to use social. And in an era of increasingly limited resources, every dollar (including the dollars invested in staff time) needs to count.
DMOs need to be social, no question about it. But they need to be social where it counts, and there's no real application with Foursquare for the DMO. Let the restaurants, bars, hotels, etc., worry about their presence on Foursquare.
Thanks Tim, I like that perspective.
Here is why it (Foursquare, Yelp, etc.) is not a part of my social strategy.
I know that some DMOs are taking the educational route with Foursquare, and frankly I think there is a possibility for the 'educational DMO' model, but I don't think it is for everyone.
For any of our DMO peers who need a quick email explanation on why they are *not* using social site X, copy and paste Tim's comment above.
Brilliant.
Troy