Skip to content
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Strategy for tourism destinations

Feature

Forecast 2012: The New Facebook

As we enter 2012, Facebook is busy introducing the masses to the Timeline. And while the new feature looks great, it means a change in approach for marketers on Facebook.

As we enter 2012, Facebook is busy introducing the masses to the Timeline. And while the new feature looks great, it means a change in approach for marketers on Facebook. Time to adapt or quit.

Sometime in early 2012 Facebook will reach one billion users.

Yes, 1,000,000,000,000 people, worldwide, will be using* Facebook.

In addition to this milestone of social dispersion, Facebook will spend the new year rolling out the much discussed Timeline UI,the Ticker,updates to EdgeRankand a few tweaks tothe Open Graph.

And by this point you have seen hundreds of articles, posts and presentations about the upcoming Timeline apocalypse.

Post more often! 6 times a day! Your posts only last 3 hours... Post photos every 3rd Thursday!

Some presenta well written perspective, while otherstake pride in shouting out the new spamming strategy.

We will hold off on the finer points of EdgeRank, humanization and the News Feed for another post. For now, let's just focus on the basic point you need to understand.

Simply put, Facebook wants you to create better content.

Period.

As Facebook reaches the maximum potential of users and hours those users can spend within the network, plus the steady growth of Google+ and pressures from advertisers, it finds itself needing marketers to create a higher quality of content.

Great content makes you spend more hours fastened to the Facebook properties and allows Facebook to show you more ads.

It is the reason why they have adjusted the EdgeRank algorithm to show you theTop Stories, rather than everything.

Everything gets boring.

And boring is the downfall of social sites...just ask Myspace.

Facebook wants better content from you.

Remarkable content.

Shareable content.

Engaging content.

If you, or your destination, cannot deliver remarkable content then you get moved out of the way. Or, more accurately, moved to the bottom of the News Feed.

But Troy, we just don't have that much remarkable content. And we certainly don't have time to post 4, 5, 6 times per day.

Well, how about a radical strategy?Like leaving Facebook.

Perhaps Facebook should not be the primary strategic focus within your social campaign.

Perhaps your content, effort and / or message is better suited for another social network.

2012 could be the year we find out.

*Usage depends on the fanaticism of the individual user.

Troy Thompson

Troy Thompson is a respected consultant, speaker and thought leader in the tourism industry. Principal at theTravel 2.0 Consulting Groupand Founder ofmark, Troy provides destinations, DMOs and CVBs with answers to difficult digital marketing questions.

Twitter| Google+| More Articles

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    Love this, Troy.

    Just two weeks ago, regarding the suffocation of social strategy, I commented here and said, "We're still in the very nascent, incipient stages of social media as a marketing platform (ESPECIALLY for destinations), and traditionally DMOs are staffed by people with experience in the traditional channels sales, print / CPG marketing, etc. We haven't hit the point yet where senior staffers have been working in the digital realm for the bulk of their careers, and as a result, the inclination is to force traditional marketing practices upon social media campaigns even though to do so is roughly akin to trying to fix your leaky kitchen faucet with a bazooka."

    The fact of the matter is that with Timeline and the other changes coming down the pipeline, to try to force traditional marketing upon Facebook is now quickly becoming utter madness, tantamount to lighting yourself on fire to try to make a point to your boss. Quite simple: FACEBOOK DOESN'T WORK THAT WAY.

    Anyone marching around and saying that they have the keys to success in Facebook's brave new world of 2012 and you must listen to them in order to succeed, like one of the articles you linked earlier, is selling you snake oil, plain and simple. (Granted, I have my own issues with HubSpot itself, but that's for another post.) This is an era of discovery and pooling knowledge not to be acting like crabs and pulling each other down in a race to the bottom of sweet, glorious mediocrity.

    EdgeRank is one of the most tightly guarded protocols in all of digital marketing, up there with Google's search results algorithms. What we know is FAR, far less than what we don't know about it; the most simple way of saying it is "Comments + Shares = Better EdgeRank." (That so many people continue to insist that Likes on Facebook increase your EdgeRank boggles my mind; then again, it makes it easier to separate the wheat from the chaff of "social media experts.")

    I always say that in email marketing, you should send timely, targeted, relevant and valuable email to people who want to receive it. You can't choose your fans on Facebook, and you can't segment your messaging, but you sure as hell can craft timely, relevant and valuable content. Don't go crying that Facebook isn't working for you when all you use it is for another platform to ship out your press releases and your EdgeRank plummets accordingly. You don't use a microwave to grill a steak, and social is the same way. The right tool for the right job.

  • / Troy Thompson

    And Mr. Brechlin takes an early lead in the race for 'Commenter of the Year, 2012.'

    As always Tim, great stuff, thank you for the comment.

    I have never been 100% convinced that Facebook will work for all destinations, all tourism organizations, no questions asked. It certainly works for some, but for all...not so sure.

    And with these latest updates to Facebook, I am less convinced that the current strategy employed by so many of our DMO peers will succeed.

    It almost reminds me of TV. Big advertisers, with big budgets and well known brands do great on TV. It is the mass media.

    Suddenly, Facebook is feeling a lot like TV advertising.

    And where does that leave the rest of us?

    Troy

  • http://buhlerworks.com/wordpress JEBworks

    In any channel it ultimately comes down to this: If you're only able to dabble in it and not make a serious commitment in terms of resources, you might as well stay away. Has been the same principle forever, whether it was TV, print ads, direct mail. You name it. A certain budget threshold has to be in place or the results will disappoint.

    As always, it is time to examine and reevaluate existing marketing programs and free up potential financial and other resources before starting to throw tactical measures at the marketplace and expect fantastic results despite what some of the self anointed gurus of the social media world might recommend.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Very true Joe.

    I am always surprised when I hear peers lament that their 'no cost' Facebook campaign did not return results.

    Make no mistake folks, Facebook is in the business of selling ads. And it would not be a very solid business model if the 'free' campaigns outperformed the 'paid' campaigns.

    Think about it.

    Troy

  • http://mediawithak.com/ Alex Kaufman

    "The fact of the matter is that with Timeline and the other changes coming down the pipeline, to try to force traditional marketing upon Facebook is now quickly becoming utter madness, tantamount to lighting yourself on fire to try to make a point to your boss. Quite simple: FACEBOOK DOESN'T WORK THAT WAY." So Money.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Nice.

  • Anonymous

    Excellent post Troy and great comments from everyone. If you are going on Facebook just cause everyone else is there you are wasting your time. I'm definitely looking forward to 2012 and how brands will respond to Facebook changes. I sure hope to see less traditional marketing and more being social. I just read that 95% of Facebook wall posts are left unanswered by brands. If that's true, why are businesses on Facebook to begin with. Great topic and very timely with the new timeline being released. As a destination, there are so many other places you can be social and engaging.

  • http://www.wilhelmus.ca Anonymous

    Like Joe and Tim pointed out, the real problem is strategic and cultural. Social isn't a bold on tactic. It's a complete re think of the role of the DMO, marketing strategies and collaboration with industry and other stakeholders.

    First social was ignored because people were afraid of it (can't control it), then treated as another broadcast channel, then a competition about who has the most fans and followers.

    In order to get the right social strategy a DMO needs the right marketing strategy. And in order to get the right marketing strategy, it needs a culture change.

    Changing culture is very hard. It takes strong leadership to navigate an organization through a cultural change.

    I think in 2012 we're going to see the first DMO's who recognize this and are initiating this cultural change.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks William, great comments.

    Completely agree with the cultural change trend for 2012.

    I know we have both spoken with, and know of, DMOs who are heading in that direction. And unfortunately, spoken with just as many who are trying everything possible to delay that change.

    Good stuff.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Agreed Milena.

    Honestly, the barrier to being great on Facebook is pretty low.

    Just answer every question and post in a timely and honest fashion...that would put your brand, destination, organization above hundreds, if not thousands of other Facebook brands.

    Unfortunately, I know of, and have worked with brands who are afraid of being honest with their consumers.

    And they are the same brands who are afraid of social media.

    Troy

  • e Tourism Summit

    In reading the comments, I couldn't help but remember the project we presented at e Tourism Summit last year in which we analyzed the Facebook pages for 25 randomly selected destinations and measured engagement during one 24 hour period in early September. What we found was that it took an average of 2226 fans to generate one comment. The real issue: recruiting fans who are most likely to comment or share.
    Realizing this, it's probably only a matter of time before a cottage industry spring up consisting of "hired" fans who are paid to comment, post and share...if in fact that isn't already happening. I think we're in store for a great DMO shake out on Facebook bifurcating into two groups: Those that can attract fans with an emotional attachment so strong that they are willing to engage and those that can't. For the latter group, FB seems to be a waste of time.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Well said Jake, thanks for the comment.

    You are spot on. It looks like we might end up with two groups...those destinations that can exert passion and those who cannot.

    And the determining factor of that passion will not be ones ability to post, tweet or blog.

    Seems like I have heard that idea somewhere before... http://ow.ly/8ia5Q

    Troy

  • http://www.wilhelmus.ca Anonymous

    One of the problems related to this is that you need passionate residents as a solid fanbase. They have destination knowledge and will generate engagement. Most DMO's aren't interested in resident because they look at FB as consumer database you can use to broadcast marketing messages to.

  • etourismsummit

    You are right! The local (or regional) fans are your strongest opportunities for comments, but you should be able to identify the most passionate and mix them in with visitors from outside the area for engagement. You need a generic page (See Toledo instead of Toledo CVB) to appear relevant to the local fan base. Then, of course, you have all the locals commenting about information of interest only to insiders (sports teams, movies playing etc). It's moving to more paid programs. Currently it runs about $1.25 2.00 to recruit a highly targeted fan.

  • http://www.wilhelmus.ca Anonymous

    Exactly. And don't forget that many local have extended networks that are outside the destination.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Great comments guys, love the conversation.

    Troy

About the author

> > Tweet Buffer 16 Comments > As we enter 2012, Facebook is busy introducing the masses to the Timeline. And while the new feature looks great, it means a change in approach for marketers on Facebook. Time to adapt or quit. is a contributor to the Travel 2.0 journal.