State Tourism Office Best Practices, The National Council of State Tourism Directors just released the results of its annual survey of state tourism office best practices. The report is an update on NCSTD's 2004 survey and provides updated measurement of how tourism offices are using current technology in their marketing and promotion efforts. It covers a whole host of topics including web design and content; online marketing efforts; site management; website related staffing and budget issues; analytics; and measuring effectiveness to name a few. Some highlights of the report based on the responses of 40 state tourism offices are:
- Median budget for digital activities (excluding salaries) was $200,000 399,000 , note however that 8 respondents reported a budget of at least $800,000(note to self , talk to our CEO!)
- While an expanded web presence has produced no incremental reduction in print costs, it has resulted in a dramatic reduction o f phone inquiries
- Median unique visitors was 500,000 999,999 visitors annually; conversely median time spent was 4 5.59 minutes (interestingly, this report also has facts on "hits"...not sure why ANYONE is tracking it)
- Most commonly reported "success" metrics are: pages visited, unique visits, length of session, volume of traffic from search engines
- The most prevalent "engagement" metric used appears to be "request for information" (be it print or electronic). Most notably, a majority of respondents reported that they would like to see a "standardized definition of inquiries shared by all state and territory offices". Troy and I are predictably psyched about this one....this bodes well for the engagement work we've been doing (read more here)
- While the report was light overall in social media best practices, most states appear to be taking incremental steps in an effort to support their fans and curate a community; surprisingly however it still appears that state/regional organizations are having trepidations about social media. They include: "lack of familiarity with social media, the amount of time it would take to implement and manage social media, and apprehension about the content of comments and / or photos that users may upload."
To see how your state stacks up against the competition, order theSurvey of U. S. State & Territory Office Website Practicesreport from U.S. Travel at: 202.408.8422.
2009 Digital Outlook ReportRazorfish recently released the latest iteration of their annualDigital Outlook Reportthis week. The 2009 version is much like their last two versions; it tracks and prognosticates consumer behavior in the digital space and includes reports on client media spending trends, mobile web usage, social influence marketing, search, and behavioral targeting. As usual, the report is a well written, absorbing read that takes you on a magical but complex 180 page journey through all things digital. Some of the big concepts were:
- The Web gets a pulse:Instant communication platforms such as Twitter and Yammer along with location aware devicesis making the web "instantly reactive"
- Content Fragmentation: If you're a content producer, your success and long term sustainability will depend on your "ability to let content travel across a myriad of platforms, devices and lifestyles" and the will to "embrace new forms of measurement, data, technology and digital infrastructure to manage complexity"
- Doing More With Less: Use the current economic climate as an opportunity to experiment. Forgo traditional buying methods and explore new avenues such as ad exchanges; leverage your fans and dabble in social influence marketing
- Email Marketing: Instead of sending email to ablack hole, use analytics to develop a long term relationship with your customer; instead of a broad based e mail newsletter, increase CTR and engagement through trigger and event driven e mails.
Time Spent on ScreensThe average American adult spends eight hours a day in front of screens, TVs, cellphones, laptops etc., and computer use has replaced radio as the second most common media activity according to a recentCouncil for Research Excellence study(FYI: Print was fourth). Key findings include:
- Surprisingly, more than 99% of screen time is TV (for 18 24 age group, TV represented 98%)
- Almost every demographic surveyed engaged in "multi tasking" or snacking on multiple screen simultaneously; people over 55 are markedly less likely to be multitasking
- 18 to 24 year olds , generally college students and new entrants into the work force , watch the smallest amount of live TV of any age group (three and a half hours a day), spend the most time text messaging (29 minutes a day) and watch the most online video (5.5 minutes a day)
This best practices report reveals some facts that indicated to me that these organizations still are not putting their web presence at the center of the overall marketing effort but rather view it as just another tool. This might have been a valid strategy at the time of the previous report five years ago but certainly not as we are about to enter the second decade of the new millennium.
The most disappointing comment supporting my opinion, is that the web presence has not produced even an incremental reduction in print costs, when in fact it should have resulted in significant reductions of these costs.
Another outdated metric of engagement is "request for information". I doubt a tour operator would be measuring results based on number of brochures mailed rather than the conversion rate resulting in number of passengers booked. What prevents a DMO from doing likewise and measure the visitors generated?
Last but not least, the reasons mentioned for not engaging in social media are equally disappointing and show a lack of readiness to embrace new methods to increase marketing effectiveness. Of course, there is lack of familiarity with new tools, that should, however, not be a reason for non engagement but rather the opposite.