As you know, ICANN has opened up a virtually unlimited sale on new, top level domain names (TLDs), which we analyzed in a recent post:12 Things To Know About New Domains.
At the same time, the lovely William from Think! Social Media and I were discussing the finer points of alternatives to hotel tax funding for DMOs. See:Top 5 Wrong Assumptions in Destination Marketing.
And we also knowthat cities such as London, specificallyLondon & Partners, have expressed interest in owning .london.
Which is an interesting perspective, considering that the agency that promotes tourism (among other London things) would control this domain name.
But what if London & Partners decided to fund the DMO with the revenue from the sale of these domains?
Now, before we go any further, for the record, I do not like, approve or endorse this expansion of the TLDs. I, like many others, see it as a pointless exercise to fill the pockets of ICANN.
But, I also know that it is going to happen.
Back to the funding idea.
Currently it appears that London & Partners is simply looking to protect their brand and the city. But, if London & Partners controls the domain (remember, .london), they also control who can use or purchase a domain name with that extension.
savoy.london
britishmuseum.london
wembley.london
The theory goes that a .london address would immediately signal an official site, certified by London & Partners.
Would members purchase that prestige, for say, $100 per year? More?
And if you had 1,000 members or small businesses by a .london domain, suddenly, London & Partners is looking at an extra $100k to spend. Yeah, yeah, I know nerds, you actually have to pay to run the registry, etc, etc, blah, blah.
Could that actually work?
Could cities such as London, New York, LA and Tokyo fund their DMO through a city specific TLD?
Ugh, I know I just saidthat DMOs should not be in the technology business, but I would rather DMOs be in the technology business than out of business.
I am not sure this funding model can, or should work, but I will be interested to see what .london becomes.
I shudder to think of what would happen if a bidding war broke out between Madison, WI, Madison, AL, or any of the nineteen Madison Counties in the United States. ICANN would be squealing like Dennis Nedry did when he saw the trick shaving cream can in Jurassic Park.
Our bid is all of the cheese in Wisconsin!
Troy
We'll throw in Governor Walker as a toss in. Y'all can have him, ICANN.
The essence behind all of it is that the industry needs to stand behind the DMO, it's leadership and the strategy for the destination. If that's the case, the funding model isn't that relevant.
What is relevant is to keep non tourism people away from the money (politicians for example). That's why the governance of the DMO and the way the money is collected is very important.
Can't say I agree wholeheartedly with this.
It's not the tourism industry that needs to stand behind the DMO , it's the DMO which needs to understand not only how to market tourism in 2012, but also how to convince the politicians, the local officials and the stakeholders of the importance of supporting tourism. The DMO can only do so much after booking a convention , it's the DMO's responsibility to get the hotels actively welcoming guests, to get politicians and developers spending money for more hotel / convention space, so on and so forth.
The DMO supports and markets for the organizations and companies which actually make tourism possible.
It's about convincing non tourism people why spending the money is important AND keeping them away from it.
Thanks William, appreciate the comment.
Ideal world, completely agree with you. And, I am sure some of our DMO friends enjoy this type of relationship.
But as I encounter and talk with DMOs, this type of issue is a common theme. And like my comments on your blog, I am wondering aloud if DMOs should put more energy into alternative funding and remove the external influences.
We can all still work together, but as you say, keep the non tourism folks away from the money.
As long as DMOs continue to collect taxes and 'earn' money from the revenue of others (hotel perspective on TID), we are always going to have this pressure.
Good conversation.
Troy
Fantastic idea, Troy! TLDs may not be the DMO funding Holy Grail , especially in smaller markets , but they could be a big piece of the puzzle. TLDs could also further establish DMOs as the authority on local information which might be worth even more than the dollars they generate.
It might be a problem to wrestle TLDs from local governments though?
Thanks Blain.
Yes, certainly, small markets cannot use this crazy idea.
I know we all love to talk about the idea of destination authority, but unless DMOs actually *do* something to reestablish that authority...join me outside the box people...they will continue to slip into the unknown.
Certainly a TLD is not an ideal solution. Hell, I don't even like this ICANN program, but I do like alternative funding sources.
And we have to start talking about some options.
Good, bad and crazy.
Troy
Based on the .travel initiative not really going anywhere, I have my doubts about this as a serious source of income except for a few major DMOs who are in less of a need to fight for support and funding to begin with. Who would pay more than a few bucks for .hicksville as the URL for their b&b?
I'm in no way against DMOs becoming more commercial. For one, it would probably change their mindset and also bring a different type of person to work. One revenue source Switzerland Tourism has developed successfully over the past fifteen years or so is matching funds for market specific programs that regional and local DMOs can buy into. Their marketing funds have been leveraged this way and the dependence on government funding has been reduced. An added benefit has been their ability to prove to politicians controlling the purse strings that their "subsidy" is in fact an investment resulting in a benefit for more levels than the national one.
Joe, I love your comments.
Yes, I of all people, completely agree that .travel was a failure. Sorry, it was. And I have my doubts as well about this program.
But, as you mention, I like the idea of challenging the traditional mindset. Yeah, this idea will not work for 90% of DMOs, but if it causes some critical thinking and spurs a few other ideas, then I am a happy writer.
And you said the keyword for all of this: investment.
Troy