Skip to content
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Strategy for tourism destinations

Technology

What Google Hotel Finder Means For DMOs

Destination marketing organizations and CVBs have long thought of themselves as the most knowledgeable guide to a particular tourism area.

Destination marketing organizations and CVBs have long thought of themselves as the most knowledgeable guide to a particular tourism area. But that claim of expertise just got a little smaller.

Yesterday,Google launched a novel little experiment called Hotel Finder. With the coverage from most tech sites being simply cut and paste,the Tnooz article being the exception, you might have missed a few subtle hints on Google's potential plan for travel and tourism.

Before we get to that, the basics onGoogle Hotel Finder: a new experimental search tool specifically designed to help you find that perfect hotel via a new mapping selection tool and comparison shopping.

So, like Kayak, just more aesthetically pleasing.

However, beyond the threat to Kayak and CVB booking engines, there is one major, yet seemingly unnoticed, implication for destinations.

Google knows more about your destination than you do.

Let's look at the first highlight from the Google blog entry: "To help you figure out where the action is, Hotel Finder shines a "tourist spotlight" on the most visited areas of U.S. cities. We select an initial shape for you based on what's most popular..."

One more time, but just focus on this part: "We select an initial shape for you based on what's most popular..."

Yeah, Google places that nifty little shape for the user. How? Because they have a wealth of data on the user, and specifically the tourist.

Searches, check ins, reviews, directions, mobile interactions, etc.

Google knows what the tourist is looking for in, I would venture to guess, every major tourism destination in the world.

That said, I would also assume that most of our tourism peers already knew this. Google has a lot of data, about a lot of things, including tourism. But, start adding together a few more pieces and picture becomes a bit more interesting:

Lets review. Google buys the people and technology from a travel guide start up, createsan experiment around city tours, knows how people begin their vacation search and has enough data to draw a box around the tourist hot spots in a location.

Take the basic travel planning / purchase funnel (Absorb Research Plan Explore Share) and it strikes me that Google is establishing a presence in 4 of the 5 segments.

Research = Search. Plan = Hotel Finder / City Tours. Explore = Mobile / City Tours. Share = Picasa / Google+.

Is the Google plan truly domination of the travel planning process? Probably more coincidence than evil plot.

But considering the increasingly robust offerings from Google, where does that leave the destination in the travel planning / purchase process?

Still a factor, but the influence of destinations just got a little smaller.

Troy Thompson

Troy Thompson is a respected consultant, speaker and thought leader in the tourism industry. Principal and Senior Tourism Consultant at theTravel 2.0 Consulting Group, Troy provides destinations, DMOs and CVBs with answers to difficult digital marketing questions.

Twitter| Google+| More Articles

  • http://SocialMediarology.com Jeremy A Williams

    I think the boundary selection tool is a HUGE win for Google. They obviously have tons of data about hotels and other tourism specific things, but by letting your users select their own "fence" for hotels, Google is giving users granular control that they simply don't have with any other OTAs or DMOs at the moment.

    I'm heading to a wedding in Fort Wayne, IN in a couple weeks and the wedding's out in the suburbs, so we don't really want stay in downtown (where all the OTAs center the search), so by using the boundary selection tool, I can look exclusively in the area I want to book the hotel, not where the OTA *thinks* I want to book.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Completely agree.

    I was in Calgary a couple of months ago, knew where the client office was and wanted to stay within walking distance. Drawing the boundary for the search would have been a huge help.

    Now, is this little experiment finished or perfect? Certainly not, but I like the direction Google is going with it.

    Troy

  • http://buhlerworks.com/wordpress JEBworks

    Excellent analysis. This just shows how much it takes today to stay ahead in the game when it comes to innovation. My guess is that most DMOs don't have the resources even if they had the sense of urgency required to compete here. Once again, integration of functions into their own web presence is the way for them to stay relevant.

    BTW the guy Michal who posted on Tnooz: Where's the innovation? Should read your comments here. Or maybe he's a genius!

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    I don't mean to sound the alarm, but I honestly think that this is a direct blow to the relevancy of DMOs at all stages. Facebook is well on its way to becoming 2011's AOL, in terms of its efforts to become the ultimate portal, but I'm not entirely sure people are paying enough attention to Google having ALL THE DATA IN THE UNIVERSE, metaphorically speaking.

    Furthermore, in addition to collecting that data (Chris Penn recently noted that Google is now adding unique timestamps to clicks in G+!), Google is slowly but surely, inexorably, marching towards giving users a way to use that data in every conceivable manner (while at the same time getting yet more data), with untold amounts of flexibility. We're at the point now that a user can go to Google and say "show me every Italian restaurant within a mile of my hotel and a medium price range," and they get it, all from a database that people unknowingly contribute to every day just by SEARCHING on Google.

    DMOs succeed because we provide authentic, reliable information to the consumer and enhance the visitor experience (mobile apps, visitors guides, visitor services, etc.). But as we've seen over the last few years, what with the explosion of TripAdvisor's popularity and the like, there's a growing trend for users to want to make their own informed decisions based on real information from real people with as much information and opportunity for choice as possible, rather than having it filtered by a gatekeeper. Visitors want to be the Keymaster AND Gatekeeper. Ultimately, Google is moving towards providing that opportunity and being able to do it better than a DMO ever could. It's frightening, quite frankly.

    The more I think about it as of late, I think our last stand, the only real opportunity for push back against the expanding influence of Google, is going to be in email marketing campaigns and social, both of which offer an opportunity for expanded authenticity (if properly utilized and planned). That said, it's even more essential now than ever to use best practices in these channels. Send timely, targeted, relevant and valuable email to addresses that have opted in to your mailings, NEVER EVER EVER buy a mailing list, don't use social to parrot your press releases, and above all ... LISTEN. If a person opts out from your mailings, unsubscribe them if someone rips on your destination in a social channel, listen to the complaint and address it if someone compliments a partner, promulgate it so on and so forth. We advocate for our destinations, but you can't effectively advocate and craft your narrative unless you listen to everything around you and you know the whole story.

  • http://rednikki.livejournal.com/ rednikki

    The key to competing in the Google marketplace is to have relevant content that brings people to the DMO website. What information can you bring together that no other website has in one place and how can you curate it in a way that makes it easier for the user?

    For example: three years ago there was no one website that had information on all the parks (state, federal, local, regional, etc.) in our region. We compiled that information in one place and significantly increased our organic search traffic.

    You are right; Google has ALL the information. The problem with receiving all the information is that it's like drinking from the data firehose. DMOs who can curate information on their destination in relevant, bite sized chunks will win.

  • Glenn Barker

    This is an excellent move by Google. Facebook has been doing a good job of promoting social media marketing in the tourism industry, but Google certainly takes things a step further and makes the entire process almost seamless for the end user. While business owners can (and should) fully develop their Google Business Listings, that information is being fleshed out every day in other ways.

    With the addition of Google + as an alternative to Twitter/Facebook, Google is becoming a true centralized online resource. I think the real question is, how do we work with them to make customer service better.

  • http://twitter.com/victoriaisley victoriaisley

    Interesting for sure. But if the role of the DMO is to inspire *incremental* travel and spending in their respective communities, ulimately they should be intercepting and influencing the visitor when they are dreaming about travel...even before those potential travelers are perched in front of that google search bar.

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    In order to win, DMOs need to, now more than ever, be a digital concierge: Be authentic, be authoritative, be real and be specific. Sites that offer a scattershot listing of everything within a field (restaurants, for example), even with mildly granular filtering, are going to quickly become outdated (if they aren't already). But are the resources there to change that methodology? I don't know. I just don't.

    The challenge, which I'm not entirely sure has been fully grasped by the destination marketing industry, is mindshare. Back in the late '80s, early '90s, people didn't talk about playing "video games" they talked about "playing Nintendo." In the late '90s, it was "PlayStation." People don't "search for something on the Internet," they "Google it." (Heck, there's an entire prank site based on that idea lmgtfy.com!) With Google's slow but steady march towards becoming that ultimate provider of information (and make no mistake, that is their endgame), it's going to be extremely difficult to combat that mindshare. There's a definitely emerging trend of "What does Google have to say about this place?"

    Now that they have the Hotel Finder, I will be ABSOLUTELY STUNNED if there isn't a similar Google app for finding restaurants and attractions within this calendar year (if they don't just buy TripAdvisor outright).

    Note that while I said it's going to be difficult, it's not impossible to combat this encroachment. I'm a big believer, as I said earlier, that email marketing and social media, two channels which are now inextricably tied to one another (as DJ Waldow says, they go together like Batman & Robin), are going to be absolutely key in this process, especially email, which is the digital glue binding all marketing. It's clear that the destination marketing industry understands that there's an urgent need to keep DMOs relevant and ensure key stakeholders of that relevancy in 2011 and beyond in the funding sense, but I'm not sure that there's enough focus being given right now to relevancy in the digital space ... because it's changing. Rapidly.

    And in this industry, complacency kills.

  • http://twitter.com/alexheimann alexheimann

    Nice blog post, I think Hotels need to be much more concerned about this than DMO's at this stage. Google is constantly analyzing clickstream data on all of it's properties to ensure they are capitalizing on all opportunities and they are probably realizing they are missing out on quite a bit of profit on hotel traffic.

    Changing up the local results for hotels (adding price, then booking links to OTA and direct to hotel) was the first start. Now they are testing hotel finder.

    My prediction.. Google runs hotel finder as an experiment to test interface/usability. Then rolls out revised,optimized interface into local results for Hotel queries.

    Then Google offers new advertising product to hotels which allows them to profit more on hotel searches.

    Would not be surprised if Google offered this product to publishers (DMOS, other travel sites) they can run on their own site for travel searches (if google gets share of revenue why not)..

    A

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    I'd think it's far more likely that instead of going the OTA route, Google takes more the tactic of a company like JackRabbit, plugging users directly into the hotels' own booking systems, sort of like Google Shopping, where it links directly to each seller's individual page for a particular item. Google likes money, yes, but more than anything else, it desires input at a Johnny 5 level of craving.

    Iiiiiiiiinnnnnnpuuuuuut...

  • http://twitter.com/alexheimann alexheimann

    yeah not sure i would take a guess at exactly how google monetizes that traffic stream, but most likely would be a CPC type model (kayak) rather than direct booking through Google, but the ITA software acquisition makes you wonder

  • http://info.boxcanyonouray.com Karen Avery

    Wow! What a win for the consumer even if it is harder on the DMO. In the end, it is the visitor that we are trying to help, right? With the end game in mind, it becomes easier to accept : )

    For individual properties, there is going to be even more transparency in pricing and competitive markets will become even more competitive. The importance of reviews are going to get even more important and the ways businesses solve problems needs to be demonstrated. It is sure hard but it just raises the bar.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Epic Tim, simply epic.

    For me it is just more evidence of the shift that will be required of DMOs, for the DMO to survive. At the core of most DMO offerings is the database of local attractions, restaurants, etc...members.

    But as you said, Google has better data, better ways to access it and no perceived bias towards a specific member.

    It is time to focus on our core strength, simplify and move forward.

    Great stuff Tim, trust me this is going to spur another article or two.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Epic Tim, simply epic.

    For me it is just more evidence of the shift that will be required of DMOs, for the DMO to survive. At the core of most DMO offerings is the database of local attractions, restaurants, etc...members.

    But as you said, Google has better data, better ways to access it and no perceived bias towards a specific member.

    It is time to focus on our core strength, simplify and move forward.

    Great stuff Tim, trust me this is going to spur another article or two.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Epic Tim, simply epic.

    For me it is just more evidence of the shift that will be required of DMOs, for the DMO to survive. At the core of most DMO offerings is the database of local attractions, restaurants, etc...members.

    But as you said, Google has better data, better ways to access it and no perceived bias towards a specific member.

    It is time to focus on our core strength, simplify and move forward.

    Great stuff Tim, trust me this is going to spur another article or two.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks for the comment Nikki, love the contrarian view.

    I certainly think there is a place for the DMO as the curator for the community, in fact I just wrote about it (Curation is the Key to Staying Relevant /2011/06/curation is the key for destinations/). The issue is that most DMOs don't have that focus.

    To Tim's point, a list of 200 member restaurants with no way to compare or contrast is not really beneficial. Sure, it is content, but it is unorganized content.

    DMOs do a great job of answering 'What', but in this new digital decade the question is 'Why'...and DMOs have a tough time with that question.

    Again, thank you for the comment, contrarian or not, all comments and thoughts are welcome.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Yes! Yes! Brilliant Victoria, spot on.

    Before the search bar is the ideal place for the DMO to make a major impact, during the Absorption or Inspiration phase.

    Leave the planning to other sites. Once they have committed to your destination, the DMO role is complete.

    I love that thought, Victoria, thank you.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Great points Glenn. Easy to forget about search, especially local search, when there are so many 'new' sites and networks.

    And if there is a downside to Google, it is the lack of customer service...how do we respond, address and correct potential issues across the Google network?

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks Joe, always love to see your comments.

    True, DMOs will have difficultly keeping up with this level of innovation. Which is part of the point. Where should DMOs focus their efforts? Competing against Google is certainly not the answer, but perhaps integration.

    You never know about Michal...he might just be. Ha!

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks for the comment Karen.

    We did not even get into the impact for hotels and hotel owners like yourself. Completely agree, pricing transparency for the industry is going to be a huge factor. No more pricing games, rack rates, etc.

    Google knows the average price and that helps the consumer.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks Alex.

    I agree, certainly a bigger impact for hotels...but, then again, my focus is the destination...so, we talked about them first.

    Thanks for the comments, really helps to broaden the conversation.

    Troy

  • / Troy Thompson

    Short Circuit FTW. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0091949/

    I knew I liked you Tim.

    Troy

  • patrickdh

    If DMO's don't have that focus, it means that it's the trade that has to pick up on this curator function without the weight of big budgets requiring offline advertising. Problem with DMO's is that they don't view customer experience path as a continuum but the trade does, so my vote would be that concierges will sit further away from the DMO's. My hope is that this model gets applied to the recently created Washington Tourism Alliance but it was not constituted with this purpose either.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Good stuff Patrick. Interesting points...in your view who else is in the 'trade' group?

    Looking forward to more.

    Troy

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    One more point that I think sometimes gets missed ... do we, as tourism professionals, take the time to think about just how much valuable information we ourselves are giving Google, which as I've pointed out is the greatest threat to a DMO's relevance within the digital marketing space?

    For example, we all have Google Analytics installed on our sites, as well we should, because it's a fantastic piece of software that really gives us an idea of who's doing what on our websites. But have you ever taken a few minutes to think, "Yeah, that's a great piece of software, but ... holy SMOKES, Google's seeing the same data I am, and probably more!" And you KNOW they're using that data we're all giving them, in exchange for a service valuable to us not quite to the point of a drug dealer and his clientele, but in the same ballpark.

    I'm not shrieking 1984 or anything, but for all the fuss we make about privacy in social media, it's kind of sobering to think of just how much privacy we've surrendered to Google. It's almost to the point that they know whether I just grabbed a Pepsi Max or a Diet Coke from my fridge, just based on my click data.

  • / Troy Thompson

    Great point Tim.

    When Google was just a search engine, it made perfect sense to try and feed it as much information as possible about our sites and business.

    But now that Google is expanding beyond a simple search engine, this is a very valid question.

    Is the trade off between free data and giving away that data worth it?

    Love that thought...

    Troy

  • Anonymous

    Agreed Troy, this was always on the horizon but Google is speeding things up. The DMO stays relevant by leading the industry and the region. Everything comes back to a focus on product. Offer something remarkable that becomes a social object in conversation and the marketing happens for you. Consumers then draw each other through the funnel. Great blog!

  • / Troy Thompson

    Thanks Rodney, always appreciated.

    Great points, I swear I could write a few more articles just on the comments from these posts.

    Troy

About the author

> > Tweet Destination marketing organizations and CVBs have long thought of themselves as the most knowledgeable guide to a particular tourism area. But that claim of expertise just got a little smaller. is a contributor to the Travel 2.0 journal.