Skip to content
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Strategy for tourism destinations

Destinationmarketing

Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Design Review: NewZealand.com

DMOs, New Zealand is not giving up the Webby without a fight! Tourism New Zealand (TNZ) is putting destination marketers on notice with a visually stunning remake of NewZealand.com , their.

DMOs, New Zealand is not giving up the Webby without a fight!

Tourism New Zealand(TNZ) is putting destination marketers on notice with a visually stunning remake ofNewZealand.com, their double Webby winner in the travel/tourism category.

Launched just months before the country plays hosts to the 2011 Rugby World Cup,TNZ continues to set the benchmark for how to boldly and elegantly deliver visitor information.

Here's why we think the site, much like feared All Blacks, is silky, smooth & a bit abrasive at times:

Visual Navigation

Like most destinations in the image building business, the New Zealand site uses large stunning images to inspire and give visitors a sense of place. What's unique about this site is that it uses"parallax" vertical scrollingto deliver a visceral experience that literally brings the country to life.Each image adjusts to the full height and width of your browser window and tells a different story.

Visitors can drill deeper to explore each experience or the place featured through a Google Map window that always gives the visitor visual context for where that image was taken. For example, the image of Milford Sound below includes ways to dig deeper into specific activities such askayakingandhikingwhile also learning more aboutMilford Soundand Queenstown.

Overall, the "layers" of the homepage comprised of the pictures, booking window, map and information layer gives the visitor a sense of depth and gives off the illusion that one is planning a trip seated at a desk with maps, guide book and pictures scattered around.

Usability & Information Delivery

From a usability and information delivery perspective, a few things stand out:

  • Not Mobile Ready:The site is clearly intended and optimized for those visitors planning a trip in the comfort of their laptops/desktops. Given that New Zealand is a long haul destination, this makes a bit of sense , one doesn't simply take a spontaneous weekend trip to Auckland from Europe or U.S. However not having a mobile friendly site when mobile devices and tablet devices are ubiquitous everywhere,especially in the country's three biggest markets (Australia, U.K., & U.S),is puzzling indeed. We're hopeful that mobile is a "Phase 1.5 item and that the TNZ team is working on a mobile friendly version that supplements the full site experience and delivers specific content geared for visitors "on the ground" . Imagine how much more relevant TNZ can be if it can show me restaurants and bars with the best deals in New Plymouth right before the US games?
  • Information hierarchy:While we love the open content model and content surfacing algorithm (see below), we've always believed that DMO's cannot and should not relinquish the role as the as the preeminent and trusted source of information in the vast sea of content on the web. TNZ should therefore use its editorial leverage to spotlight and serve up the most relevant content first. For example, searching for "rugby world cup" surfaces up pretty much every piece of content tagged with these keywords including deals, individual lodges, and travel agents. Thishandy TNZ guide to the eventhowever lies buried in the search results.
  • Navigation:We like the unobtrusive and intuitive main navigation at the top; however, the choice of blue text over black background makes us wonder if readability is an issue for folks with visual impairments.
  • Load times:When the site first launched, we noticed that images on the homepages loaded very slowly and even the vertical scrolling was painfully slow. While the initial slow load times appear to have been fixed at the time of this writing, load times will be an ongoing issue and must be monitored.

Bold Content Strategy

Content throughout the site is centered on interests and places and every piece of content (stories, photos, videos etc.) is meticulously tagged so that visitors can easily find them associated around their topics or places of interest. While this is similar to the VisitFlorida site, the similarities end there.

What's interesting about the New Zealand content model is that while the agency still remains the authoritative voice of the site, they're also sourcing content from YouTube & Flickr.

Furthermore, TNZ has taken the unprecedented step of ceding control and allowing anyone, regional tourism partners, operators and sellers, travelers and locals alike, to contribute content and edit and/or flag existing content.While this shift in strategyunderstandably troublesregional tourism associations and small business who're strapped with resources, the advantage of being on a site that attracts nearly a million visitors per month cannot be discounted.

Patrick Verryt, New Zealand's Online Managercommentson these advantages and says that:

"...travel businesses that contributed an article were 58 times more likely to be contacted by a potential customer than those without an article on the site. Furthermore, businesses that loaded travel deals were four times more likely to be contacted by a customer and three times more likely to have their pages shared with a friend."

Content Scoring System

Finally, due to the volume of content on the site, a nifty algorithm that gauges both user interest and richness and depth of the content, determines what is surfaced. We love this because it rewards those businesses who have taken the time to ensure accurate and informative content.

However, it will be interesting to see how this system handicaps smaller businesses and tourism groups that may not have the resources to keep contributing and editing content on the site. In addition, the ability of TNZ to highlight and bubble up pages and content that they know will be relevant to certain keywords per the rugby example mentioned above, will certainly also be important as content pours into the system.

Backend Publishing/Syndication

All the content for NewZealand.com and its partner publishing sites are syndicated from the Operator Database (OD) that controls the listing for tourism operators/sellers and the Operator Registration Database (ORD) that allows businesses to add content such as itineraries or stories to the system. As far as we can tell, these systems are similar to theAustralia Tourism Data Warehouse(ATDW) andTravel Oregon's ORBin that they give tourism entities a "one stop shop" to publish and syndicate content.

Conclusion

Striking the right balance between delivering inspiration and practical travel information to visitors while simultaneously making it easy and seamless for local tourism organizations to contribute content is an immensely difficult and unappreciated task.

While the New Zealand site iscertainly not the perfect, we can't help but admire and cheer the tenacityof the TNZ team and its digital agencyShiftin breaking new boundaries in using technology to tell the destination story.

Editor's Note: We made several attempts to interview the folks at Travel New Zealand for this post but were unable to get a response.

  • http://www.kaywalten.com Kay Walten

    WOW it is a great site. Can I ask what agency did it? Incredible.

    • / Troy Thompson

      Hi Kay,

      Thanks for the question.

      That would be Shift, out of New Zealand. (http://www.shift.co.nz/)

      Troy

      • http://www.kaywalten.com Kay Walten

        Troy love your blog! Would love to interview you some day if you are into it!

        • / Troy Thompson

          Hi Kay,

          Thank you, appreciated. Certainly. Feel free to send me an email: troy (at) travel2dot0.com.

          Troy

      • http://www.kaywalten.com Kay Walten

        Troy love your blog! Would love to interview you some day if you are into it!

    • http://twitter.com/mosherifdeen mosherifdeen

      Agree , definitely a game changer in the DMO world. BTW it looks like Shift was also the agency for the 2 previous versions of the site that won the Webbys for tourism/travel

  • http://twitter.com/alexheimann alexheimann

    This site is breathtaking but has serious usability. Great concept and I am sure this will inspire DMO sites over the next few years, but I am sure the average visitor to the site who is looking to get some research and trip planning done will get frustrated. NZ would have been better served to test this UI on a smaller microsite of a specific region or for a campaign, rather than the whole site..

    • / Troy Thompson

      Great thoughts Alex, thank you.

      Personally, I am torn on this one. I agree with the idea of a localized UI test, but I love the overall site.

      Mentioned it on Twitter just a bit ago, wonder if TNZ was thinking they could get people to slow down and really experience the site? Rather than just load, click, click, skim and close.

      But, it is extremely difficult for one site to change the browsing patterns of the internet masses. Admire the assumed goal, but think it might have been too much.

      And I agree with your inspirational point. I have a strong feeling we will see several variations quite soon.

      Good stuff.

      Troy

    • http://twitter.com/mosherifdeen mosherifdeen

      Agree Alex; DMO's have always been in the inspiration game but digital has given us the tools to stay relevant at every stage of the trip planning process. It will be interesting to see how the site evolves the information delivery as it reviews analytics. Might make for a great Part 2 post in the next few months.

  • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

    It's a visually striking site, but it has violated a crucial rule of Web design: Outside of the top navigation, the whole homepage is in Flash. And it's a HEAVY, heavy site , it's making so many external object calls that it takes forever for pages to load (I'm pretty sure I heard my iPad squalling and mewling when I pulled the site up on it).

    I like it a lot, but there's just a little too much emphasis on form over function. Usability is a huge hurdle.

    • / Troy Thompson

      Thanks Tim.

      Heavy is an understatement. But you know what is odd? In doing some research on the site, I found that newzealand.com/us/ scored pretty well on the Google Page Speed test (http://code.google.com/speed/page speed/).

      89 out of 100. Not bad, and certainly better than I expected.

      But, the usability of such a large site is a huge question mark for me. Just from the simple standpoint that there is a lot of content to scroll through on the homepage alone.

      That said, easily the most fascinating tourism site redesign I have seen in 5 years.

      Whether that is good or bad, I am not sure.

      Troy

      • http://twitter.com/timbrechlin Tim Brechlin

        You know, at the end of the day, at least a DMO had the gumption to roll up a snowball and toss it into the fires of hell, just to see what kind of a chance it has , and as you and I are continually saying, that's the kind of thinking DMOs need today and in the days, months and years to come, rather than having tunnel vision and proceeding business as usual.

        It's far from perfect. But at least it's SOMETHING new.

        • / Troy Thompson

          Agreed. A new approach to attracting visitors to New Zealand.

          Kudos for having the vision to attempt such an ambitious site.

          Troy

        • http://twitter.com/mosherifdeen mosherifdeen

          Hi Tim , Definitely! It's really nice to see a DMO who's willing to completely change the things have been done in order to stay relevant and more importantly make a difference to visitors.

  • http://twitter.com/jameshacon James Hacon

    I was in the pilot destination group in my last project, managing the St Clair Beach Resort in Dunedin.

    I loved the initial concept, driving a more interactive and engaging experience for users. I too believe it was a brave step and congratulate Patrick and team at TNZ on helping to put NZ ahead of the game in terms of an NTO's online presence.
    I feel the final design is a bit clunky with some real usability issues, perhaps most worrying is the potential for important information and articles to get lost in the ever growing content.

    Many operators I have spoken too, seem to see it as 'one more thing' they've now got to think about. In a country where an enormous percentage of our tourism operators have a small number of FTE's, the aim of making it as easy for smaller businesses to get noticed as their larger counterparts, as promised from the outset, is simply not the case. Larger operators have the time and resources to populate this site with their content, whilst smaller operators simply do not.

    Once TNZ have rolled out its content sharing model, where it will distribute its information to third party sites as well as through to Regional Tourism Organisations and the I Site network, I'm sure it will act as a great incentive to see operators start embracing the opportunity.

    Many of us assumed that the site would have been mobile from the outset, allowing it to be used as some what of a mobile visitor guide once in NZ, particularly considering all articles and businesses have to be positioned accurately. I can only assume this is one of the later phases.

    It will be interesting to see what happens next, last I heard is that this is phase 1 with several more to come; however shocked to hear of Patrick Verryt's impending departure from TNZ in the coming weeks.

    • / Troy Thompson

      Hi James,

      Thanks for the comment (and the tweet), greatly appreciated.

      I can certainly understand the concern of smaller tourism operators. I will be interested to see how TNZ addresses this issue going forward.

      I would fully expect this is only Phase 1 of the project, but agree, still some unanswered questions.

      Troy

    • http://twitter.com/mosherifdeen mosherifdeen

      @jameshacon Thx for your insightful comments. Totall y agree with you and Troy , how the stories of the smaller, lesser known places in NZ are curated and "bubbled up" will ultimately spell success for the site. That really is the challenge for many large tourism destination sites and I am really intrigued by how TNZ will handle it.

      When you folks tested it out in Dunedin, what usability issues came up and how did they end up being resolved in the final site?

  • Jim Brody

    Rule #1 Mo , Never talk about Fight Club. Seriously, on the top level, this is where "maturity" on line is heading. It's no longer about the technology alone, the DMO data base alone, how you use design or video alone. Pat Verryt and the folks at TNZ have figured it out: It's making the connection between the DMO, the product, the operators, the advocates, using social, video, graphic and text elements, to create a complete story that the individual can craft to create the "sense of place" that fits their perspective on what a vacation should be. This version certainly has some kinks to be worked out, but I think this is where we are going in general, and we will see more DMO's develop this concept even further.

    • / Troy Thompson

      Hey Jim,

      Good stuff. To your credit, you have been talking about this concept for months...if not years...the idea of a complete storytelling experience. Creating that connection.

      Technical challenges aside, I would agree, in general newzealand.com is a glimpse into the very near future for DMOs.

      Love the conversation.

      Troy

About the author

Mo Sherifdeen is a contributor to the Travel 2.0 journal.

More writing