Skip to content
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Strategy for tourism destinations

Destinationmarketing

Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Solving the Print / Digital Travel Guide Debate

Will digital visitor guides and mobile apps replace the printed travel guide? It is a question that occurs yearly, just as the DMO or CVB begins to print the new guide.

Will digital visitor guides and mobile apps replace the printed travel guide?

It is a question that occurs yearly, just as the DMO or CVB begins to print the new guide.

Commonly held wisdom and anecdotal evidence suggests that visitors like the feel of a paper guide. But do they?

Or are the merely in love with anything free?

Sure, they carry it with them, but if a DMO was to replace it, with say,a destination focused iPad/iPhone app, what effect would it have on the visitor experience?

Rather than taking the word of your publisher or digital agency, who yes, have an agenda, let's solve the problem with a simple A/B test and some research.

A/B Testing the Value of Your Printed Visitor Guide

Step 1: Forcing the Digital Visitor Guide Download

First, we need to replicate the experience as if there was not a printed travel guide available. By forcing a digital visitor guide version we can a) gauge the impact on website traffic / flow and b) create a segment of visitors who traveled without the aide of the printed travel guide.

  1. Remove the printed guide order form from your website.
  2. Update any on site promotional materials to remove the printed travel guide reference.
  3. Update the order form page with either a) the digital visitor guide, b) your CVB mobile app or c) your mobile website.
  4. Capture an email address for all requests.
  5. Run test for one (1) week or until a sufficient test group has been established (400 people should do it).

Step 2: Removing the Paper

Okay, step two...removing the printed visitor guide from the Visitor Center. Blasphemy! Don't worry, we will put them back...maybe. While step one will show us the impact on the virtual visitor, we also need to see the effect on the physical visitor. Plus, your Visitor Center is the prime location for consumer feedback.

And we know these people actually visited the destination.

  1. Remove the printed travel guide from the shelves / rack.*
  2. Upon request, direct requests to either a) your CVB mobile app or b) your mobile website.**
  3. Capture an email address for all requests.
  4. Run test for one (1) week or until a sufficient test group has been established (400 people should do it).

* Yes, you might have to tell people you 'ran out.' If they get really pissed, tell them you will meet them behind the building in 5 minutes with a copy.

** Either a CVB mobile app or mobile website will be required for this test.

Step 3: Research

Time to send out a survey or two. We are going to want three (3) groups for this test: theDigital Visitor Guidegroup, theVisitor Centergroup and a control /Printed Travel Guidegroup.

To truly determine value, we need tohave specific goals in mind to help us evaluate the printed travel guide. Asking the consumer if theylikedthe guide is neither insightful, nor helpful.

  • Did the lack of a printed visitor guide adversely affect the decision to travel to your destination?
  • Did the guide content encourage unexpected visitation to local tourism business(es)? Measure for print v. digital visitor guide.
  • Was the guide brought on the trip? Again, print v. digital.
  • Determine the cost savings v. advertising revenue potential.

Additionally, we will need to develop some reporting around demographics, preferences and perhaps frequency.

There you have it, a logical approach to determining the value of your DMO's / CVB's official visitor guide to the actual visitor.

Does this mean you should actively work to eliminate your printed visitor guide? Of course not.

But it should provide you with a better answer than...they like holding a paper guide.

Bonus Tip

So, you have a fancy new iPhone / iPad app, right?Are you actively demoing the app for your guests?No. Why not?

In a brilliant mashup of physical space with digital info, Visit Napa Valley has set up anapplication demo station inside their Visitor Center.The CVB purchased a nice wood table, 6 iPadsand placed a focus on their portable visitor concierge.

A simple, yet effective way to introduce your visitors to that new iPhone application.

Extra Bonus Tip

What happens after a web visitor requests your printed visitor guide? For most destinations it is a simple, yet standard 'thank you' page. But why just say thank you?

Use that thank you page to push and promote your mobile application. These are people who have just requested information about your destination...they are hungry for knowledge!

A perfect opportunity to present your mobile offerings.

Assuming it is more than just a repeat of the website they are already on.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1346252871 Nathalie Dumon

    Hello Troy.
    Great article.
    We, in Ghent, also looked into the same question.

    For now we are sticking to paper guides because:
    1. data roaming is very expensive in Belgium (especially for tourists with a foreign phone subscripton) so people bring the guide in stead of the digital device.
    2. Our visitors are often WHOPS (Wealthy Healthy Older People) who don't have a smart phone, or sometimes not even a cell phone
    3. In focus groups 30 % of the people said they prefer paper
    4. apparently business people consider the guide as a 'gift' (in a goodiebag)

    The Nappa idea is very interesting. I'm considering that ; )
    We are going to open a completely new state of the art visitor centre on the 2th of March. A few pictures here:
    https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.10150520244575208.369040.103828440207&type=3&l=2bd6186ca8

    • / Troy Thompson

      Hi Nathalie,

      Thank you for the comment, greatly appreciate the international perspective.

      Love your approach to this question. The fact that you have research and reasons as to why Visit Ghent is sticking with the printed guide is refreshing. Kudos.

      Plus, actual focus group testing...+1.

      And wow, look at that visitor center. Okay, you are going to have to help us with a guest article on the tech / approach to that visitor center. Impressive.

      Troy

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1346252871 Nathalie Dumon

        Thanks! and glad to help. You can reach me on nathalie.dumonATgent.be!

        • / Troy Thompson

          Wonderful thanks.

          I will certainly reach out to you, our readers love seeing new tech + visitor centers.

          Troy

  • http://twitter.com/IowaBicycle IowaBicycleCoalition

    Troy, great article.

    • / Troy Thompson

      Thanks, and thanks for the comment.

      Yes, I was actually at the Iowa Governor's Conference on Tourism this year...you guys, well bicycling, made the visitor guide cover.

      As to your question, yes, I think it could.

      While I am not sure of the product you offer, I could imagine a situation where this would work.

      Let's say you have an iPad/iPhone app, then you could place a dozen, two dozen iPads in strategic stops along a bicycling route. At each stop, the riders could come in, use the app and visit the attraction...the winery in your example.

      For those who did not know about the guide, it is a great demo tool to encourage a download. Then, your marketing takes place via the app.

      Plus, you could likely generate revenue from the partners along the route.

      Honestly, I would focus on building a mobile / tablet friendly site or app (like we are talking about), before a website.

      That said, I would take a look at http://rideoregonride.com/ for more inspiration. I am sure our contributing writer Mo Sherifdeen would be happy to chat with you about the project.

      Any other questions, please, just ask.

      Great conversation.

      Troy

      • http://twitter.com/IowaBicycle IowaBicycleCoalition

        I recall. Loved your session, but not long enough. :) I think you could have done a day long workshop. I hold a conference for bicycling. Maybe we should have you out to do a workshop during our conference.

        • / Troy Thompson

          Always happy to make a return trip to Iowa. Just keep me in the loop.

          Troy

  • Frederic Gonzalo

    Bonjour Troy!

    Boy, oh boy, this is one burning topic that has been on my pet peeves list for quite some time. If you had asked me a few years ago, I probably would have said "out with all the printed stuff, already".

    Nowadays, however, my position is more nuanced. Consider this:
    In the US, more than 9 out of 10 customers has a mobile phone, but only 44% have smartphones. This number is expected to reach 50% by 2013;
    In Canada, where I focus my time and energy, stats are not even that good. Close to 7 out of 10 have a mobile, and only 30% have smartphones;
    Nathalie, from Belgium, alluded to roaming fees in Europe. Well, in Canada, it's just plain brutal. Cost is therefore a major deterrent, so many folks just won't bring or use their mobile while on leisure trip (they might on a business trip, when on a company plan);
    Finally, looking at travelers' demographics show a clear skew towards slightly older crowd, which tend to prefer reading brochures on paper , OK, I will have to admit, I am occasionally part of this mindset even though I'm 40 (is that considered old? Let's not go there...)

    So where does that leave us? I think you've hit it on the nail that DMOs and CVBs need to try different things if they seek to achieve different results. Removing paper brochures won't happen overnight, but I believe quantities could and certainly should be reduced through the years. We may reach a point, in 10 15 years from now, when a "print on demand" scheme becomes possible. In the meantime, innovative destinations will try out mobile apps and location based services in order to better service their clients while reducing printing & distribution costs of the good old brochure.

    Will be interesting to see how DMOs and CVBs adapt in coming years.
    Cheers,
    Frederic

  • / Troy Thompson

    Hey Frederic,

    Thanks for the comment, greatly appreciated.

    I completely agree. At this point, I don't think it is realistic to simply stop printing visitor guides. But, for some destinations, the ratio of print v. digital could change dramatically if an A/B test such as this was conducted.

    While there is value in the print guide, I think most DMOs do a poor job of promoting other sources of information.

    Mobile apps, mobile websites, Twitter feed, etc. all could and should be promoted as strongly as the printed guide...especially at the Visitor Center.

    But, it is easier to just give away the guide to consumers who are never going to say 'no' to free.

    Personally, really looking forward to the impact and developments around print on demand. It seems like a step backwards in terms of technology, but as you said, a segment of our visitors are always going to prefer the printed guide.

    The question is, how do we make it cost effective for us, and relevant for the visitor.

    Great comment.

    Troy

    • http://twitter.com/IowaBicycle IowaBicycleCoalition

      I am intrigued by the print on demand model. I read the Napa Welcome center website and they employed print on demand from the tablets. If you are using a cloud based printing service, that shouldn't be too hard to coordinate in a welcome center with a wireless printer.

      What I really like is the metric created by on demand printing. You have a better sense of what your customer is requesting. The old model was a guesstimate of what demand might be. If demand was less than supply, the tendency was to push the bigger stack of remaining brochures to the front of the display.

      I think the other technology to embrace is a push to mobile device. If I see an app I love on Google Market, I can send the app to my tablet or phone or both. There has to be some way of pushing a pdf, file, or video to a mobile device.

      • / Troy Thompson

        Agreed. Most likely, the consumer is not going to sit there and re print all 150 200 guide pages. Instead, only printing the key pages they feel are worthy enough for the ink.

        Now that would be an interesting app to develop. An iPad app for just the Visitor Center, let the visitor build his/her ideal brochure and then be able to print the customized / personalized brochure on site.

        Plus, let them download the app and then choose if they want the print or digital version.

        Like Offbeat Guides (http://www.offbeatguides.com/) from our friend Dave.

        Good stuff.

        Troy

        • http://www.patjem.nl/ patjem

          nd when the tourist visits the visitorcentre to print his travelplans sell him tickets for stuff that is on his travellist. That could drive commission bases fee, covering the printingcosts.

          • / Troy Thompson

            Great point, I like the idea.

            Troy

  • http://twitter.com/BlueIon BlueIon (C. Simpson)

    Hey Troy,

    First time commenting here. I've been following along silently for a while and love your thinking.

    One thing I'd like to add to your testing scenario is whether visitors are willing to PAY for the guide (at least the online or app version).

    If CVBs could create a document so compelling (more than just a bunch of ads), it could move from a cost of doing business to a profit center (or at least offset the printing costs for the physical version).

    Look at what Politico and HuffPost are doing with the production of ebooks / Kindle singles. Who says CVBs can't do the same thing?

    To me, the question isn't printed or not printed. It's how can we continue upping the value of the content that is produced (in any form) so it improves the visitor experience during their visit. And if it's so great people will pay for it , even better.

    Obviously it's not a simple task, but it's something high on my list of things to develop and pursue in the coming year(s).

    BTW , as part of the digital team that works with the Charleston Area CVB... we don't have an agenda. :)

    Chris Simpson

    • / Troy Thompson

      Hey Chris,

      Thanks for the comment, trust me, the first one is the hardest. Heh.

      Love the idea. Actually, while researching this article, I can across several old tourism brochures (1950 1972) with featured pricing on the cover. $.95 appears to have been the common asking price.

      These were guides and brochures produced by the same DMOs who now give them away.

      Certainly something to be said about perceived value. If the content in the guide truly is valuable, then charging for that content should only increase the value in the mind of the consumer.

      As you said, not a simple task, but a very important one.

      Good stuff.

      Troy

  • http://twitter.com/UrbanTGApps UrbanTG

    There are some functions out there that can not be integrated to a travel guide, a book can not pick the best location to visit according to a mixture of your budget and your trip preferences, traditional printed travel guide are without a doubt inspiring and good reading while on the road, but technically lack of intelligence, imagine you set up a budget and set your trip preference to more nightlife, and escapism than museum and cultural places, only a smart app on a smart device can find out and bring to the top the places that matches your settings, this is what we are trying to build on UrbanTG.com

    Halim

  • / Troy Thompson

    Hi Halim,

    Thanks for the comment. And kudos on UrbanTG.

    Your point about intelligence is very true. As we move forward, intelligence, relevancy, content and quality will drive the market.

    Difficult to argue the value of a printed guide v. the possibilities of a digital guide with respect to intelligence.

    That said, there is still a need for both, but how can we make those printed versions as intelligent as possible. For example, a custom printed guide based on visitor preference.

    It is an interesting question and I am excited that people such as yourself are pushing the technology forward.

    Troy

  • http://www.patjem.nl/ patjem

    Great article. It just gave me some new ideas for one of my clients,http://www.verkeersbureaus.info. We are also discussing this topic (in Dutch, sorry folks) on http://www.reismanagers.nl/gaan we stoppen met papieren brochures.html

    • / Troy Thompson

      Hey Patrick,

      Thanks for the comment, appreciated. Glad you liked the article...certainly a lot of opportunities in the space.

      No worries on the link in Dutch, we are huge in Holland! Heh.

      Troy

About the author

Troy Thompson is a consultant, speaker and writer focused on destination marketing, tourism strategy and the digital shift in travel.

More writing