Skip to content
Travel 2.0 Consulting Group Strategy for tourism destinations

Destinationmarketing

Travel 2.0 Consulting Group The Social Cost of Co ops

I am extremely fortunate. Fortunate to have peers, fans and followers that will take time out of a busy day, ignore their kids or postpone lunch to read my thoughts, ramblings and musings.

I am extremely fortunate. Fortunate to have peers, fans and followers that will take time out of a busy day, ignore their kids or postpone lunch to read my thoughts, ramblings and musings on tourism. It is an honor that humbles and amazes each time I consider it.

If you will allow, I assume that part of the appeal is my honest outlook on all things tourism.You trust and respect my opinion, even if you don't agree with it.

Never shy to share my thoughts via an article or tweet, I would call out close peers...Mo, Tim, Katie...if they ever fucked up a campaign. To my knowledge this has yet to happen.

Continuing a pattern of painful honesty, I introduced this nugget of wisdom into a recent edition ofthe always intriguing #tourismchat.



You can catch up on the mayhem that ensued viaa simple hashtag search of #tourismchat.

Let's expand those 140 characters and see if I can explain my reasoning and rationale.

The crux of my argument is that for a DMO or CVB to attain a position of trust it must eliminate any conflicts of interest.While co op advertising can likely be traced back to the first time a DMO and two members were in the same room, the perspective that social media has placed upon transparency should cause us to reconsider the cost / benefit of such a relationship.

If DMOs want to become the expert representative for their region, a one stop shop (ugh) for everything about the destination or a trusted resource for vacation planning information, how can they accept money to promote one attraction, restaurant or hotel (over another) while making recommendations without the potential perception of bias?

Social media has forced changed upon us.

DMOs are actively taking money from a hotel for placement in a print piece, while answering 'where should I stay?' questions on Twitter.

Is that a conflict of interest? Would a DMO promote one member or sponsor over another without regard for the best answer? Probably not.

But does the consumer know that?

Whether the social interaction is related to a contest, campaign or general information is not important. The larger issue is what position the DMO wants to maintain with the consumer. In the past, we have walked the line between marketer and journalist. Promoting those who pay, while attempting to create the appearance of independence.

What is the DMO?

A marketing machine for the highest bidder or an independent local expert for the tourist?

I am not saying one is right or one is wrong. Simply that I don't think they can continue to exist within the same organization.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with building an audience, creating content and then selling access or marketing opportunities to those with the ability to pay for said access. Google, WhereTraveler, Orbitz, Southwest, even Disney, have created profitable outlets with this very crude explanation of the business model.

Perhaps I am creating a conversation that is not required. A mountain from a molehill. No big deal, right? The traveler does not care.

DMOs should keep selling access to sponsors, advertisers and members. Being in the same business as Google, Where or Orbitz is a good thing. Outlets with plenty of content, regardless of expertise.

After all, who needs expert travel advice?

  • http://twitter.com/ckjchambers Chris Chambers

    Interesting topic of discussion Troy.

    I agree with the sentiment of your post, but can't help but wonder if there isn't different solutions for different channels and that digital channels will absolutely provide increased co operative opportunities in the future for DMO's.

    Specifically I think these two comments need a little further discussion:

    "Whether the social interaction is related to a contest, campaign or general information is not important."

    and

    "I am not saying one is right or one is wrong. Simply that I don't think they can continue to exist within the same organization."

    I can see a way of developing solutions for the different channels for the benefit of the potential visitor, as well as DMO and tourism product.

    Underlining all this is that DMO's need to remain focussed on providing the information which helps potential visitors to have the best possible visits to our corner of the world.

    One of the most important assets a DMO can develop now is their own digital distribution channels. In Tourism Queensland's case this is an audience on facebook (over 500k), an audience of 22k on "the twitter" and an email database of nearly 750k. It follows reason that as DMO's build these audiences then the audiences will become an outlet for new co operative opportunities.

    I can only speak on behalf of Tourism Queensland, the opportunity for tourism businesses in our state to use our channels is mostly not pay for play. Industry regularly post information to our facebook wall so that visitors to that page will see the posts and we re tweet and tweet interesting tid bits of content which is solely dependant on that being content we think is interesting and meets the brand values of our destination.

    General information requests are off limits as a co operative opportunity. A twitter question asking for accommodation recommendations is generally referred to our website. It will likely be that way for some time yet I would say.

    We have developed a white label promotional engine for facebook which we do allow as a co operative opportunity for the industry. It's definitely a pay to play space. It's a competition / promotion which we use to drive engagement on our page, raise awareness of q Queensland product / destination as well as interest in a holiday offer / package and the partners own facebook page / channels. We've run two such campaigns and generated great results.

    I'd say that if a DMO is doing their job properly they will already be thinking about how to develop co operative opportunities across all channels, including social. Tread weary, but we must innovate into this space, while respecting the environment we're innovating in.
    Chris

About the author

Troy Thompson is a consultant, speaker and writer focused on destination marketing, tourism strategy and the digital shift in travel.

More writing