While everyone lamentsthe loss of The Washington State Tourism Officeand its annual $1.8 million budget, I consider this recent turn of events as an opportunity for big change in how visitors exchange information and talk about travel.
I want to seize this opportunity to create abrand newwebsite andmodernmedia platform to connect the best of WA State with its travelers.GoWAState.com will be a highly interactive travel guide, much different than its informational only state run predecessor. It will be a comprehensive resource fortravelers, created and curated by experts and travelers, independent of bureaucratic organizations, member run chambers and paid content.
I've worked as a travel journalist for the past 13 years and have written for more than 100 publications, including TravelChannel.com, National Geographic Traveler, Conde Nast Digital Media, Islands, Sunset, DailyCandy.com, Fodors.com and Destination Weddings and Honeymoons.
I understand the informational and digital resources people need to travel and have the professional credibility and connections to make GoWAState.com happen.
From the best hotels, hiking trails and most innovative restaurants, to cool events, must have services and places to shop, my editorial (and ethical) rule of thumb is this:If I wouldn't recommend something to my friends, I won't put it on the site.
Credibility will always be a conflict of interest for DMOs, who cater to meeting planners and travel operators and cow tow to industry stakeholders.
Due to economic politics, it's inevitable , I get it.
But, I don't like it and I'm sick and tired of travel experiences being spoon fed to tourists based on paid memberships instead of unbiased merit.
The amount of pay for play bullshit I've seen over the years would make any unsuspecting traveler's head spin, and as a result, there are a handful of destinations on my editorial blacklist. Sure, this paradigm may generate dollars, but it lacks integrity and is ultimately, not in the best interest of the traveler.
In addition to increasing transparency, DMOs need to step it up when it comes to understanding the social media landscape. Tourism is no longer a one sided informational resource. DMOs need to embrace and engage new digital tools and create an interactive conversation and community or they will quickly become irrelevant.
Just last week, the "marketing" voice from a local Chamber of Commerce tried to school me on social media. I did some quick R&D on this guy only to find he has minimal online presence, exactly four followers on Twitter and an egg as his avatar. I have four times the amount of followers on my personal Twitter account than his entire chamber. Can you say "irrelevant?"
Since I'velaunched fundraising for GoWAState.com, I receive nasty emails and DMs from DMOs on a daily basis, which leads me to believe I've struck a nerve.
Good. I'm going to keep calling bullshit on the pay for play model and keep pushing for change.
I love travel, I love Washington State and it's about time the traveler is given the resources they need and put first.
Editor's Note
I asked Charyn to pen this guest post after a few exchanges via Twitter in reference to GoWaState.com. I like the passion she brings to this conversation. While I both agree and disagree with some of her points and approach, I feel that it is an important perspective for our DMO peers to recognize and understand.
Troy
Laudible goals, however perhaps a tad naive. The perception may be that convention bureau websites are biased towards their members, however the same goes for the advertisers that your proposed site will feature. Someone's got to pay the bills, and whether you call them members or advertisers it amounts to the same thing.
I also think you're grossly underestimating the costs of building and maintaining such a site.
Wish you all the best. Washington is the only state to remove all gov't funding for its tourism bureau. A questionable decision to be sure, and one that I suspect will be revisited and reversed a year or two from now.
Good stuff Darren, thanks for the comment.
Troy
Darren,
Thank you for your comment. It is possible to create a dynamic where advertising does not drive editorial coverage. It's a model I've personally followed for 13 years as a journalist and plan to apply to GoWAState.com.
That's a hell of a post, Charyn.
I agree with some of your points (particularly that tourism is no longer a one way street), but some others give me pause. For example, you write, "DMOs need to embrace and engage new digital tools and create an interactive conversation and community or they will quickly become irrelevant."
Now, as Troy will tell you, I've been screaming bloody murder regarding DMOs' relevance in the digital space, but I have to take issue with the idea that DMOs need to create a conversation. I don't think it's possible for a DMO to truly *create* a conversation or a community.
A DMO can provide the opportunity, the breeding grounds for that conversation, that community, and it can foster such movements in their incipient stages and beyond, but at the very roots, any conversation or community , a church, a forum, a social club, even an AA meeting , is what its participants make of it.
I also see another flaw in your ideas. First, you say, "If I wouldn't recommend something to my friends, I won't put it on the site." But, two sentences later, you say, "But, I don't like it and I'm sick and tired of travel experiences being spoon fed to tourists based on paid memberships instead of unbiased merit."
There's an inherent contradiction, here. By saying that if you wouldn't recommend it to your friends, you won't put on the site, you're already admitting to bias. You're still acting as the gatekeeper, just with a different methodology from member based DMOs.
There's a lot of food for thought in here.
Tim, as always, the comments are great. Love the thoughts on community. I think you are spot on, we can contribute, but not truly create.
As DMOs continue to work through the opportunities and challenges that have developed in the past 5 years, we must begin to select our integration points carefully. We don't need to be involved in every single step of the travel funnel, just the spots where we can make the most impact.
Troy
Thanks for your comment, Tim.
A lot of good points here. I do believe it is possible for a DMO to create a forum/space where people will engage in active dialogue. The DMO must engage and encourage visitors/readers on an ongoing basis. Social media is a commitment and it needs to be a two way street. Very few DMOs (IMO) seem to grasp this. Chambers tell me to post things on their Facebook site, yet rarely "share" or "RT" their members news/information. It has to be a give and take and I find very few DMOs that have grasped this concept. People *want* to talk and exchange ideas , I see it every week in the travel tweetchats I participate in. I want that level of interaction to translate into GoWAState.com , its site, forums and SM efforts.
Let me clarify another point. We want to assemble a team of "local experts" around the state to recommend people, places and experiences. We believe that everyone is an expert on something, and those are the experiences that need to be shared (and rarely do get shared under the current pay for play DMO model). *Everyone* is fair game for editorial consideration, not just paid members, etc. As a long time journo, I've seen how ad dollars influence coverage and people should get play based on merit, not paid membership. I'll help coordinate how things are culled for the site, but I won't be the ultimate "gatekeeper." I believe there's a great deal more credibility to the model I propose than an pay for pay dyanmic could ever offer.
There's a lot of room for improvement with the current model...
That's a hell of a post, Charyn.
I agree with some of your points (particularly that tourism is no longer a one way street), but some others give me pause. For example, you write, "DMOs need to embrace and engage new digital tools and create an interactive conversation and community or they will quickly become irrelevant."
Now, as Troy will tell you, I've been screaming bloody murder regarding DMOs' relevance in the digital space, but I have to take issue with the idea that DMOs need to create a conversation. I don't think it's possible for a DMO to truly *create* a conversation or a community.
A DMO can provide the opportunity, the breeding grounds for that conversation, that community, and it can foster such movements in their incipient stages and beyond, but at the very roots, any conversation or community , a church, a forum, a social club, even an AA meeting , is what its participants make of it.
I also see another flaw in your ideas. First, you say, "If I wouldn't recommend something to my friends, I won't put it on the site." But, two sentences later, you say, "But, I don't like it and I'm sick and tired of travel experiences being spoon fed to tourists based on paid memberships instead of unbiased merit."
There's an inherent contradiction, here. By saying that if you wouldn't recommend it to your friends, you won't put on the site, you're already admitting to bias. You're still acting as the gatekeeper, just with a different methodology from member based DMOs.
There's a lot of food for thought in here.
Tim, as always, the comments are great. Love the thoughts on community. I think you are spot on, we can contribute, but not truly create.
As DMOs continue to work through the opportunities and challenges that have developed in the past 5 years, we must begin to select our integration points carefully. We don't need to be involved in every single step of the travel funnel, just the spots where we can make the most impact.
Troy
You go girl! I think you have identified a crucial issue with your post and I concur with much of what you have said. The big challenge will be funding. Dynamic web site with the capabilities you discuss cost money.
Hi Jack, thanks for the comment. Good point, and the ultimate challenge, funding the idea. Kickstarter is an excellent solution, if the community feels strongly about the project.
Troy
Hi Jack, thanks for the comment. Good point, and the ultimate challenge, funding the idea. Kickstarter is an excellent solution, if the community feels strongly about the project.
Troy
Thanks for your comment, Jack, and thanks for chiming in Troy. Yes, funding will be the biggest challenge. I've had success with Kickstarter in the past with other projects, so hopefully it is the right crowdfunding platform for this project. If not, I will rethink the funding, but either way, will figure out a way to make this happen.
First off, congratulations on a very valuable effort and best of luck in making it a reality. A fresh start without political baggage and a sense of entitlement all too often inherent in a member based bureaucratic setting is to be welcomed. When I look at that budget figure quoted, it was a seriously underfunded one, hardly able to make a serious difference in the marketplace.
This could become an interesting test case of a blank slate, customer centric effort in how to market a destination using the social web tools available today that allow the creation of a community around a common interest. With the right open minded approach I think funding can be achieved by a mixture of revenue streams both advertising and commission based. Will it be easy, no. Possible, yes by recruiting those able to think outside the proverbial box.
I would also encourage an effort to get into a partnership with one or more of the new trip planning ventures offering great technology not found on existing DMO sites which make for a much better user experience. Again, due to lack of flexibility and breaking of established traditions these start ups exist separately from the established destination sites when more cooperation between them would benefit the traveler.
Again, a great opportunity here to bring some movement into the DMO reality. Good luck!
Thanks for the comment Joe. Appreciated.
If I was launching a new destination focus tourism site, you would be one of my first calls.
Troy
Glad to be on your list, Troy! Feel free to spread the number ;)
To me, this is the beauty and the challenge in the current marketing landscape. Everyone now is a publisher and all have access to tools that allow for the potentially to reach the same number of people as an advertiser that purchases a Superbowl ad. That said, this also allows anyone to publish good and bad material which I'm sure we've all seen. In any case, good information/content should rise to the top and whether it's a DMO or another organization it hopefully all makes for a better planning experience. I certainly applaud your efforts Charyn and I hope that you're able to differentiate and execute your site in the manner you describe as I'd love to read it!
Good stuff Eric, thank you sir.
Love that though, everyone is now a publisher.
Troy
Fascinating, productive conversation. As I have said for too many years now, if all a DMO is known/understood to provide is information, we can and should and will be replaced.
But the real role of the DMO is more than that. It is about economic development , OPM , Other People's Money , and getting it into our communities. Using those tax dollars to offset those collected from locals to deliver quality of life to our residents.
Sure, some of the DMO job indeed is about making sure we're providing quality, consistent information and it's available not only on our own websites, but directed to the multitudes of other content providers as well.
Meeting planners and group travel buyers need more than just unbiased destination information to make their decisions. They need to be TARGETED, STALKED AND SOLD. DMOs do this, and it is a critical part of our role. Communities will feel the bigtime bottom line benefit of visitor investment when those visitors come in planeloads and busloads.
But with the VISITOR/CUSTOMER at the center of all our decisions, our focus has to be more than just information. We solicit to bring groups to our communities. We provide a wealth of services to them when they are here. But we also , in a much bigger picture perspective , represent the voice of the customer back to the community , supporting or leading on initiatives that will drive more visitor revenues, and thus ease our city and state bottom lines. Airport expansions, new flights or cruises, sidewalks and green spaces, pet friendly amenities and bike paths, convention centers, arts centers, sports venues, too. And about traditional core city services that deliver on the visitor experience , safety, cleanliness, pothole free streets, accessible sidewalks.
Hi Maura,
Thanks for the comment, great to hear your voice in this conversation.
So helpful to listen to various opinions on a subject such as this. In the end, it will make those of us willing to adapt a stronger organization.
I love your opening line, and it is the truth. A DMO is more than just information and a brochure rack. A DMO is a piece of the community, a needed source of economic impact, an important service that makes the standard of living better for everyone, not just tourists.
DMOs are more than just information, and we need to start letting people know.
Troy
Hi Maura,
Thanks for the comment, great to hear your voice in this conversation.
So helpful to listen to various opinions on a subject such as this. In the end, it will make those of us willing to adapt a stronger organization.
I love your opening line, and it is the truth. A DMO is more than just information and a brochure rack. A DMO is a piece of the community, a needed source of economic impact, an important service that makes the standard of living better for everyone, not just tourists.
DMOs are more than just information, and we need to start letting people know.
Troy
As others have said, I think the goals expressed here are indeed laudable. However, I think you're tilting at windmills a bit if you think the system can be so radically overturned. It's not so much the obligation to members that creates the conflicts you cite, but in many communities its the obligation to the taxpayers, usually the hoteliers, that demands an equal and fair promotion of those entities. The structure that drives so much tourism promotion in the US will not come undone so easily because of the millions of tax dollars (and not just membership dues) involved.
My question to you is, why can't we have it both ways? There's plenty of room for the model you describe to coexist alongside the one you have criticized, and be successful from both a financial and editorial perspective.
Hi Chris,
Thanks for the comment. Great thoughts.
Personally, I love the conversation that this guest post has developed, and your question of having it both ways brings a new perspective to the equation. Thanks for that.
And I agree, the taxpayers...hotels...are the common source of demand. But, they are also the most common source of tax revenue. Until the industry finds a 'better' way to tax the visitor, beyond a hotel night, the hotel industry will remain a close partner.
Troy
Hi Charyn,
At first a bit disgusted about some of your claims of what Washington Tourism was/did/should have done, now totally punching my fist in the air and behind you 100% after reading this. Thank you for understanding the politics, pay to play and WST history better.
Many of the people who have been involved want a change. We are usually a bit younger and have had experience in other industries besides Tourism.
There were also quite a few people working on the non pay to play interactive travel guide before the some plugs (and egos) were pulled. Who knows what will happen, but I can tell you, if you do it, you will need help. And there are thousands of photographers, writers, reviewers, travelers and WA ambassadors just awaiting the opp. Let me know if you need help finding them.
Rock on with your bad ass self, grrrl!